A group approach to genetic counselling of cardiomyopathy patients: satisfaction and psychological outcomes sufficient for further implementation

Abstract

The introduction of next-generation sequencing in everyday clinical genetics practise is increasing the number of genetic disorders that can be confirmed at DNA-level, and consequently increases the possibilities for cascade screening. This leads to a greater need for genetic counselling, whereas the number of professionals available to provide this is limited. We therefore piloted group genetic counselling for symptomatic cardiomyopathy patients at regional hospitals, to assess whether this could be an acceptable alternative to individual counselling. We performed a cohort study with pre- and post-counselling patient measurements using questionnaires, supplemented with evaluations of the group counselling format by the professionals involved. Patients from eight regional hospitals in the northern part of the Netherlands were included. Questionnaires comprised patient characteristics, psychological measures (personal perceived control (PPC), state and trait anxiety inventory (STAI)), and satisfaction with counsellors, counselling content and design. In total, 82 patients (mean age 57.5 year) attended one of 13 group sessions. Median PPC and STAI scores showed significantly higher control and lower anxiety after the counselling. Patients reported they were satisfied with the counsellors, and almost 75% of patients were satisfied with the group counselling. Regional professionals were also, overall, satisfied with the group sessions. The genetics professionals were less satisfied, mainly because of their perceived large time investment and less-than-expected group interaction. Hence, a group approach to cardiogenetic counselling is feasible, accessible, and psychologically effective, and could be one possible approach to counselling the increasing patient numbers in cardiogenetics.

Group genetic counseling: An alternate service delivery model in a high risk prenatal screening population

“…Patient satisfaction was high in both formats. A pilot study of group genetic counseling for symptomatic cardiomyopathy patients showed an increase in perceived personal control and a decrease in anxiety . Other models studied in the cancer genetic setting, such as telegenetics and a DVD presentation followed by shorter in person genetic counseling, have shown feasibility and acceptability of these approaches when compared with traditional genetic counseling …”

A dynamic systems view of clinical genomics: a rich picture of the landscape in Australia using a complexity science lens

“…The systems perspective applied in this study presents a holistic and nuanced view of processes, influences and interactions. Many studies have examined processes and interactions at the unit level [ 32 ] or focused on a specific group of patients [ 33 ] or health professionals [ 34 ]. Others have looked at global endeavours in genomic medicine [ 16 ], describing and contrasting genomic programs in different countries.…”

Changes in empowerment and anxiety of patients and parents during genetic counselling for epilepsy

“…The GCOS-18 shows a satisfactory internal consistency (Cronbach's a ¼ 0.77) and excellent test-retest reliability (intraclass correlation coefficient ¼ 0.92) [25]. Anxiety was measured with the short 6item version of the Spielberger State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI), which is validated for measuring the psychological outcome of genetic counselling [21,27,28]. Questions on baseline characteristics were included in the first questionnaire (demographic characteristics) and extracted from medical records if consent was obtained (information on epilepsy and genetic testing results).…”