“…Today it is known that energetic gamma radiation is produced in abundance by thunderclouds [Parks et al, 1981;Parks, 1985, 1992;Eack et al, 1996aEack et al, , 1996bEack et al, 2000;Moore et al, 2001;Dwyer et al, 2004aDwyer et al, , 2004bDwyer et al, , 2005Smith et al, 2005], contrary to Wilson's expectation. It is also recognized that the substantially greater ranges in air of gamma rays (in comparison with b rays of the same energy) are needed for energetic particles to escape the dense atmosphere to be detected in space [Williams et al, 2006].…”