A Geometric Morphometric Evaluation of Equid Tooth Shape at Natural Trap Cave, Wyoming

Abstract

Natural Trap Cave is a sinkhole cave located in Big Horn County in northern Wyoming. The cave preserves many Quaternary taxa, including pollen and large carnivorous and herbivorous mammals such as various felids and ungulates. Many of these taxa went extinct in North America following the late Pleistocene megafaunal extinction. The cave was first excavated in the 1970s and 80s by teams from the University of Kansas and the University of Missouri, and more recently by teams from Des Moines University, The University of Adelaide, and The University of Rochester, along with a wide variety of volunteers. Specimens from this cave have been used to elucidate floral change in the area, disentangle ancient food webs, and extend the hypothesized range for Beringian wolves. Horses are the most common megafaunal group from this site, encompassing two genera: Equus and Haringtonhippus, the “New World stilt‐legged” horse, based on post‐cranial elements and mitochondrial DNA. Some recent studies have shown that horse taxa can be identified by tooth occlusal surface morphology. This study aims to test if isolated equid cheek teeth from Natural Trap Cave can be identified to the genus level, between Equus and Haringtonhippus using geometric morphometrics. 2D landmarks and sliding semi‐landmarks were taken around the periphery of a set of upper cheek teeth, including the areas of greatest curvature at the metastyle, mesostyle, parastyle, and around the protocone and post protoconal valley. Principal component analyses on known specimens do in fact separate Equus and Haringtonhippus, and this difference is statistically sigificant, with the primary difference being the width of the protocone. Additionally, molars and premolars also occupied significantly different areas of morphospace, opening up the possibility of identifying tooth position on unknown specimens as well. With the abundance of isolated horse teeth (either Equus or Haringtonhippus) from Natural Trap Cave, having a reliable means to distinguish between genera will allow us to better study the ecological differences between them and better understand the environment and faunal interactions in late Pleistocene Wyoming. Support or Funding Information NSF EAR/SGP 1425059 (Natural Trap Cave Revisited: Ancient DNA, Climate and the Megafaunal Extinction) Julie Meachen, PI