“…Previous studies have reported a high concentration of consonant vs. vowel substitutions in patients with AoS, but a more balanced distribution in patients with PhI (e.g., Burns and Canter, 1977;Monoi et al, 1983;Romani et al, 2011a with an overlapping smaller patient sample 3 ), so that a concentration of errors on consonants is considered by some a defining characteristic of AoS (Darley et al, 1975). Finally, error patterns where more errors are made on vowels, have been reported, but in tasks not involving articulation, such as spelling (e.g., Cotelli et al, 2003;Cubelli, 1991), or in patients with fluent speech (three single cases described, respectively, by Caramazza et al, 2000, Romani et al, 1996and Semenza et al, 2007. This suggests that difficulties of phonological selection can target either type of segment, but that, in apraxic patients, difficulties of articulation produce more sound errors on consonants.…”