A decade of cigarette taxation in Bangladesh: lessons learnt for tobacco control

Abstract

Bangladesh has achieved a high share of tax in the price of cigarettes (greater than the 75% benchmark), but has not achieved the expected health benefits from reduction in cigarette consumption. In this paper we explore why cigarette taxation has not succeeded in reducing cigarette smoking in Bangladesh. Using government records over 2006–2017, we link trends in tax-paid cigarette sales to cigarette excise tax structure and changes in cigarette taxes and prices. We analysed data on smoking prevalence from Bangladesh Global Adult Tobacco Surveys to study consumption of different tobacco products in 2009 and 2017. Drawing on annual reports from tobacco manufacturers and other literature, we examine demand- and supply-side factors in the cigarette market. In addition to a growing affordability of cigarettes, three factors appear to have undermined the effectiveness of tax and price increases in reducing cigarette consumption in Bangladesh. First, the multitiered excise tax structure widened the price differential between brands and incentivized downward substitution by smokers from higher-price to lower-price cigarettes. Second, income growth and shifting preferences of smokers for better quality products encouraged upward substitution from hand-rolled local cigarettes ( bidi ) to machine-made low-price cigarettes. Third, the tobacco industry’s market expansion and differential pricing strategy changed the relative price to keep low-price cigarettes inexpensive. A high tax share alone may prove inadequate as a barometer of effective tobacco taxation in lower-middle income countries, particularly where the tobacco tax structure is complex, tobacco products prices are relatively low, and the affordability of tobacco products is increasing.

Price, Income, and Affordability as the Determinants of Tobacco Consumption: A Practitioner’s Guide to Tobacco Taxation

“… 22 Third, countries subject to downward substitution to cheaper cigarettes in the presence of increasing prices may not see a decrease in sales or may even experience an increase in sales. 23 …”

Tobacco use in school students in Afghanistan, Oman and Kuwait and association with parental monitoring: analysis of data from Global School-based Student Health surveys

“…Taxation has been used to reduce the tobacco use epidemic, but results are inconclusive (7). A recent study in Bangladesh concluded that high tax share alone may not be a good measure of effective tobacco taxation in low-income countries, especially in countries with a complex tax arrangement, relatively cheap tobacco products and a growing affordability of tobacco products, which emphasizes the need for better and targeted health promotion activities (8). Although cigarette smoking has decreased in people under 18 years in the United States of America, the rate did not change from 2017 to 2018.…”

The Diabetes TRACK (by NEHEP) Vs Bangladesh

“…Bangladesh has been identified as a high-achieving country for several tobacco control measures, including tobacco taxation, health warning labels and anti-tobacco mass-media campaigns. The high level of achievement for Bangladesh in cigarette taxation is, however, contradicted by an increase in per capita cigarette consumption [57]. Urban male smokers in Bangladesh consume more cigarettes than bidis and smoke more per day than rural smokers.…”