A critique of the English national policy from a social determinants of health perspective using a realist and problem representation approach: the ‘Childhood Obesity: a plan for action’ (2016, 2018, 2019)

Abstract

Background The UK government released Chapter 1 of the ‘Childhood Obesity: a plan for action’ (2016), followed by Chapter 2 (2018) and preliminary Chapter 3 was published for consultation in 2019 (hereon collectively ‘The Policy’). The stated policy aims were to reduce the prevalence of childhood obesity in England, addressing disparities in health by reducing the gap (approximately two-fold) in childhood obesity between those from the most and least deprived areas. Methods Combining a realist approach with an analysis of policy discourses, we analysed the policies using a social determinants of health (SDH) perspective (focusing on socio-economic inequalities). This novel approach reveals how the framing of policy ‘problems’ leads to particular approaches and interventions. Results While recognising a social gradient in relation to obesity measures, we critique obesity problem narratives. The Policy included some upstream, structural approaches (e.g. restrictions in food advertising and the soft-drinks industry levy). However, the focus on downstream individual-level behavioural approaches to reduce calorie intake and increase physical activity does not account for the SDH and the complexity and contestedness of ‘obesity’ and pays insufficient attention to how proposals will help to reduce inequalities. Our findings illustrate that individualising of responsibility to respond to what wider evidence shows is structural inequalities, can perpetuate damaging narratives and lead to ineffective interventions, providing caution to academics, practitioners and policy makers (local and national), of the power of problem representation. Our findings also show that the problem framing in The Policy risks reducing important public health aims to encourage healthy diets and increase opportunities for physical activity (and the physical and mental health benefits of both) for children to weight management with a focus on particular children. Conclusions We propose an alternative conceptualisation of the policy ‘problem’, that obesity rates are illustrative of inequality, arguing there needs to be policy focus on the structural and factors that maintain health inequalities, including poverty and food insecurity. We hope that our findings can be used to challenge and strengthen future policy development, leading to more effective action against health inequalities and intervention-generated inequalities in health.

Childhood obesity prevention trials: A systematic review and meta‐analysis on trial design and the impact of type 1 error

“…This is further complicated by our need to design evaluations that, rather than looking for a measurable impact of obesity reduction at an individual level (i.e. with treatment), seek to find smaller alterations to energy imbalance that over time reduce excess weight gain 9,130,131 …”

Explaining the UK’s ‘high-risk’ approach to type 2 diabetes prevention: findings from a qualitative interview study with policy-makers in England

“…This detracts attention away from the socioeconomic causes of disease (such as the obesogenic environment) 45 56 57 and oversimplifies the complexity of diabetes development. 21 Inherent in this strategy is the assumption that health inequalities are due to individual life choices, not the underlying social causes of disease. 45 56 Subsequent individual health promotion messaging in lifestyle interventions promotes the belief that people should be able to overcome their structural barriers, making rational choices despite difficult living circumstances.…”

“…There will always be a need for individual-level interventions based in primary care; however, to reduce the prevalence of conditions such as diabetes, these must be done in parallel with upstream population-level initiatives addressing the wider determinants of health. 21 26 27 51 67 …”

Public health interventions tackling childhood obesity at European level: A literature review

“…OWOB and OB prevalences seem to have plateaued in the Nordic countries. Childhood obesity: a plan for action ( Griffin et al, 2021 ) England Department of Health To Significantly reduce England’s rate of childhood obesity within the next 10 years, to review the nutrient profile model, update School Food Standards, provide guidance on reducing sugar content of foods, and set targets for product composition. 2016, 2018, 2019 Εmphasis has been placed on collaboration with the private sector.…”