A critical discourse analysis of the link between professional culture and organisational culture

Abstract

PurposeDespite the fundamental role of culture in an organisational setting, little is known of how organisational culture can be sometimes determined/influenced by professional culture, particularly in the global south. Using Nigeria as a research focus, this article uses critical discuss analysis to examine the link between professional and organisational culture.Design/methodology/approachThis study uses qualitative research approach to establish the significance of professional culture as a determinant of organisational culture among healthcare organisations.FindingsWe found that the medical profession in Nigeria is replete with professional duties and responsibilities, such as professional values and beliefs, professional rules and regulations, professional ethics, eagerness to fulfil the Hippocratic Oath, professional language, professional symbols, medicine codes of practice and societal expectations, all of which conflate to form medical professionals' values, beliefs, assumptions and the shared perceptions and practices upon which the medical professional culture is strongly built. This makes the medical professional culture stronger and more dominant than the healthcare organisational culture.Research limitations/implicationsThe extent to which the findings of this research can be generalised is constrained by the limited and selected sample of the research.Practical implicationsThe primacy of professional culture over organisational culture may have dysfunctional consequences for human resource management (HRM), as medical practitioners are obliged to stick to medical professional culture over human resources practices. Hence, human resources departments may struggle to cope with the behavioural issues that arise due to the dominant position taken by the medical practitioners. This is because the cultural system (professional culture), which is the configuration of beliefs, perceived values, code of ethics, practices and so forth. shared by medical doctors, subverts the operating system. Therefore, in the case of healthcare organisations, HRM should support and enhance the cultural system (the medical professional culture) by offering compatible operating strategies and practices.Originality/valueThis article provides valuable insights into the link between professional culture and organisational culture. It also enriches debates on organisational culture and professional culture. We, therefore, contend that a strong professional culture can overwhelm and eventually become an organisational culture.

Unpacking the Organizational Culture as a Sustainable Distinctive Competence in Knowledge Intensive Firms: The Harvestplus Case in Colombia

“…Since the 1980s, OC has been recognized as an important phenomenon in business management (Adisa et al, 2020). OC is constructed from basic assumptions that determine the adoption of values, expressed through visible manifestations or artifacts (Schein, 2004).…”

Impact of corporate culture on product innovation capacity: Evidence of Vietnam commercial bank

“…It is essential to establish and maintain an organizational culture to increase and improve organizational performance through innovation (Moon, Choi, & Armstrong, 2018). Adisa, Oruh, and Akanji (2020) have found that corporate culture significantly influences organizational innovation. According to Shanker, Bhanugopan, Van der Heijden, and Farrell (2017), organizational culture shapes and reinforces innovative workplace behavior by influencing how employees communicate in the workplace, encouraging employees to form positive relationships and encouraging healthy competition (Hassani & Mosconi, 2022;Meng & Berger, 2019).…”

The impact of COVID-19 on the work–life balance of working mothers: evidence from Nigerian academics

“…For female academics who are mothers, it has become a herculean task trying to make it through daily work and family life during COVID-19, especially in Nigeria, which has a less egalitarian, collectivistic tradition (Mushiqur et al, 2018). With a population of almost 200 million spread across over 250 ethnic groups (Worldometrics, 2020), the Nigerian society is a sociocultural system that accepts high power distance (Hofstede, 1980), idealising expectations of unquestionable obedience and submission towards superiors (especially men) with acclaimed status and authority (Adisa et al, 2020). Furthermore, the existence of gender stereotypes and the marginalisation of female voices based on age-long glass-ceiling ideologies is a major hindrance to the career development and WLB of professional women (Akanji et al, 2019).…”

“…, 2018). With a population of almost 200 million spread across over 250 ethnic groups (Worldometrics, 2020), the Nigerian society is a sociocultural system that accepts high power distance (Hofstede, 1980), idealising expectations of unquestionable obedience and submission towards superiors (especially men) with acclaimed status and authority (Adisa et al. , 2020).…”