A Constructivist Model of Bank Branch Front-Office Employee Evaluation: An FCM-Sd-Based Approach

Abstract

The banking sector is one of the primary drivers of economic development. This sector has been affected by various crises throughout its history – most recently, the 2008 financial and economic crisis. In response, banking institutions have had to make diverse changes to their procedures and deal with new concerns related to changes within markets. One of the main recent developments in this sector is the new commercial function assigned to bank branch front-office employees, who have become responsible for selling financial products and services, as well as recruiting and retaining clients. As a result, the sector needs new employee performance evaluation methods in line with banks and staff members’ requirements. This study combined fuzzy cognitive mapping techniques and the system dynamics (SD) approach to develop a well-informed performance analysis system for assessing bank branch front-office employees. The proposed system was validated by the Business Process Management Competence Center director at Millennium BCP – a Portuguese private banking corporation. The main difference between the model constructed in the present research and current evaluation practices is that the criteria were collected directly from multiple specialists working at different commercial banks, who deal daily with this decision problem. The model’s theoretical and practical implications are also discussed.

A sociotechnical approach to vaccine manufacturer selection as part of a global immunization strategy against epidemics and pandemics

“…The latter are interpreted as causal relationships between concepts (Fonseca et al, 2020;Martins et al, 2020) and given influence signs (i.e., + or -) or influence weights, which results in a signed or weighted map, respectively. The cognitive mapping technique facilitates groups of actors' efforts to manage complex decision problems more effectively (Eden & Ackermann, 2004;Paes de Faria et al, 2020). This method-also called mental modeling-has been applied in varied contexts to analyze and understand disorganized decision problems (Kolkman et al, 2005;Natividade et al, 2020).…”

“…Although cognitive maps are deeply affected by the decision makers' perceptions (Tegarden & Sheetz, 2003), these maps provide added value by visualizing the group's perspectives and real-life experience, thereby overcoming various limitations of purely statistical approaches (cf. Martins et al, 2020;Paes de Faria et al, 2020). For example, the issue of religious or philosophical beliefs opposing immunization is often omitted from discussions, but the cognitive mapping process was able to detect the effect of this issue.…”

Strategic visualization: the (real) usefulness of cognitive mapping in smart city conceptualization

“…Cognitive mapping-related techniques facilitate a more effective management of complex decision problems by groups of decision makers (Eden and Ackermann, 2004;Ferreira et al, 2019;Paes de Faria et al, 2020). These techniques-also called mental model methods-have been applied in different contexts to analyze and comprehend unstructured decision-problem situations (Kolkman et al, 2005;Natividade et al, 2020).…”

Sustainable Development in Education – Automating Curriculum Assessment

“…Since a cognitive system typically works on knowledge base, or corpus, created by investigating various structured and unstructured data sources, this technology is suitable for gauging knowledge for our corpus of teaching materials. The cognitive computing methods have been meaningfully applied in socio-economic research to assess bank branch front-office employees' activity (Paes de Faria et al, 2020), when a fuzzy cognitive mapping method was integrated with system dynamics, or to identify the determinants of e-commerce in small and medium-sized enterprises (Barroso et al, 2019).…”