A Complementary Approach to Promoting Professionalism: Identifying, Measuring, and Addressing Unprofessional Behaviors

Abstract

Vanderbilt University School of Medicine (VUSM) employs several strategies for teaching professionalism. This article, however, reviews VUSM's alternative, complementary approach: identifying, measuring, and addressing unprofessional behaviors. The key to this alternative approach is a supportive infrastructure that includes VUSM leadership's commitment to addressing unprofessional/disruptive behaviors, a model to guide intervention, supportive institutional policies, surveillance tools for capturing patients' and staff members' allegations, review processes, multilevel training, and resources for addressing disruptive behavior.Our model for addressing disruptive behavior focuses on four graduated interventions: informal conversations for single incidents, nonpunitive "awareness" interventions when data reveal patterns, leader-developed action plans if patterns persist, and imposition of disciplinary processes if the plans fail. Every physician needs skills for conducting informal interventions with peers; therefore, these are taught throughout VUSM's curriculum. Physician leaders receive skills training for conducting higher-level interventions. No single strategy fits every situation, so we teach a balance beam approach to understanding and weighing the pros and cons of alternative intervention-related communications. Understanding common excuses, rationalizations, denials, and barriers to change prepares physicians to appropriately, consistently, and professionally address the real issues. Failing to address unprofessional behavior simply promotes more of it. Besides being the right thing to do, addressing unprofessional behavior can yield improved staff satisfaction and retention, enhanced reputation, professionals who model the curriculum as taught, improved patient safety and risk-management experience, and better, more productive work environments.

Professionalism among multicultural medical students in the United Arab Emirates

“…[16] It is speculated that the faculty and the administration of UAE medical schools may be reluctant to pursue an expulsion because of a lack of a national consensus to support punitive action against academic misconduct. Certainly, the paucity of data limits definitive conclusions about the best approach to prevent academic misconduct in UAE medical schools.…”

Student response to reports of unprofessional behavior: assessing risk of subsequent professional problems in medical school

“…Strengths of a graded-response ECN process include the ability to maintain a supportive and counseling-dominant environment until a pattern is recognized that justifies stronger action [27]. In this respect, our ECN program reflects the tiered approach of Hickson et al with licensed physicians that emphasizes progression from a ‘cup of coffee’ conversation to more formal, structured intervention when warranted [28]. …”

Hospital Doctors are Professionals and Communicate in their Own Specific Way

“…For example when management changes one of their personnel, even when he or she is good, it might be a reason for discomfort. They will express this discomfort without knowing what the exact reason is [9].…”