A Compilation and Review of over 500 Geoscience Misconceptions

Abstract

This paper organizes and analyses over 500 geoscience misconceptions relating to earthquakes, earth structure, geologic resources, glaciers, historical geology, karst (limestone terrains), plate tectonics, rivers, rocks and minerals, soils, volcanoes, and weathering and erosion. Journal and reliable web resources were reviewed to discover (1) the frequency of misconceptions by subject matter, group (primary, middle-school, high-school, middle-/high-school, college, pre-service teachers, in-service teachers, and undefined) and source (journal versus web); and (2) the pattern of misconceptions across age groups and (3) directions for future research. A total of 502 misconceptions were discovered, with over 40% targeting a middle-and high-school audience. Plate tectonics comprised 19% of all misconceptions, with another 14% and 13% associated with weathering/erosion and historical geology, respectively. Over 80% of all the misconceptions were derived from peer-reviewed journals or web sources, the rest originated from reliable sources on the World Wide Web. The supernatural origin for many of the geoscience phenomena listed here is abandoned by middle school, but in other cases, some misconceptions seem robust through adulthood. Examples of such misconceptions include the origin/pattern of earthquakes, thickness of the earth's crust, oil's origin, movement mechanisms for glaciers, co-existence of humans and dinosaurs, water movement within karst terrains, the nature of plate boundaries, the power of water as an agent of geomorphic change, what constitutes a mineral and a rock, thickness of the soil layer, the distribution of volcanoes, and the difference between weathering and erosion.

A Qualitative Study Concerning the 6th Grade Students’ Conceptual Structures about the Cell Concept

“…Pek çok konuda çok sayıda çalışma yayınlanmıştır (Artun ve Coştu, 2011;Francek, 2013;Longfield, 2009;Wandersee, Mintzes ve Novak, 1994). Bunlardan çıkarılabilecek en önemli sonuçlardan biri öğrencilerin formal eğitim almadan önce doğal ve teknolojik dünya ile ilgili büyük miktarda bilgi ve fikirle dolu olduğudur.…”

Recovering Knowledge for Science Education Research: Exploring the “Icarus Effect” in Student Work

“…Forty years of research into students' thinking has led to significant theoretical and practical advances; for example, explicating students difficulties as "alternative conceptions" has underpinned development of tools for identifying conceptions and determining learning outcomes of newly designed instructional approaches (Bektasli, 2013;Francek, 2013;Yalcin, Altun, Turgut, & Aggul, 2009). Several fundamental issues remain subject to considerable debate, including the nature of student conceptions (diSessa, 2006) and the value of notions of alternative conceptions (Clement, Brown, & Zietsman, 1989).…”

Junior secondary school students' conceptions about plate tectonics

“…Since many of the processes operate on spatial and temporal scales that cannot be observed directly, they are often misunderstood by students (Dodick & Orion, 2003). Francek (2013) has developed a comprehensive list of school and university students' preconceptions about Earth's structure, historical geology, plate tectonics, earthquakes, volcanoes, rocks and minerals, and weathering and erosion, finding that most alternative conceptions were about plate tectonics. Some examples of the most widely held alternative conceptions about physical geography phenomena include: Earth's crust is several hundred kilometers thick Steer, Knight, Owens, & McConnell, 2005); tectonic plates are underground and are not exposed at the Earth's surface (American Association for the Advancement of Science, 2015); volcanoes are found in places that have high temperatures, like at the equator (Dahl, Anderson, & Libarkin, 2005); and weathering and erosion are synonymous (King, 2010).…”