A comparison of transoesophageal echocardiographic Doppler across the aortic valve and the thermodilution technique for estimating cardiac output

Abstract

SummaryThis study was undertaken in order to elucidate the differences between various planes of measurement and Doppler techniques (pulsed-vs. continuous-wave Doppler) across the aortic valve to estimate cardiac output. In 45 coronary artery bypass patients, cardiac output was measured each time using four different Doppler techniques (transverse and longitudinal plane, pulsed-and continuous-wave Doppler) and compared with the thermodilution technique. Measurements were performed after induction of anaesthesia and shortly after arrival in the intensive care unit. Optimal imaging was obtained in 91% of the patients, in whom a total of 82 measurements of cardiac output were performed. The respective mean (SD) areas of the aortic valve were 3.77 (0.71) cm 2 in the transverse plane and 3.86 (0.89) cm 2 in the longitudinal plane. A correlation of 0.87 was found between pulsed-wave Doppler cardiac output and the thermodilution technique in either transverse or longitudinal plane. Correlation coefficients of 0.82 and 0.84 were found between thermodilution cardiac output and transverse and longitudinal continuous-wave Doppler cardiac output, respectively. Although thermodilution cardiac output is a widely accepted clinical standard, transoesophageal Doppler echocardiography across the aortic valve offers adequate estimations of cardiac output. In particular, pulsed-wave Doppler cardiac output in both the transverse and longitudinal plane provides useful data.

Executive summary on the use of ultrasound in the critically ill: consensus report from the 3rd Course on Acute Care Ultrasound (CACU)

“…Mitral and tricuspid valve issues can be captured by TOE with a combination of transverse and longitudinal planes in the multiplane facility. Assessment of aortic valve function is more difficult but possible using a deep transgastric view in a transverse plane (0°) in the stomach or a LAX view (120°) at the gastro--oesophageal transition [22]. This view, in fact, allows for the dynamic imaging of all four valves.…”

Can a NICO monitor substitute for thermodilution to measure cardiac output in patients with coexisting tricuspid regurgitation?

“…Heart rate was determined from an electrocardiographic trace using the R-R interval between the first and last VTI. CO was calculated by multiplying the mean VTI by the mean AVA and heart rate [24][25][26]. To test intra-observer variability, measurements of CO by TEE were repeated twice by an echocardiographer.…”

Assessment of loading conditions with cardiac ultrasound. A comprehensive review

“…Stroke volume can be derived from the area under the curve of a transaortic valvular Doppler signal (velocity time integral, VTI), obtained in a deep transgastric view [35,36]. VTI is actually the distance at which one red blood cell is pushed with a single contraction of the left ventricle.…”