A comparison of patient-reported quality between inpatient services for mental and physical health: A tertiary-hospital-based survey in China

Abstract

BackgroundIt is widely acknowledged that quality of mental health services is routinely worse than physical health services across countries. However, studies separately investigating mental health services often report high-level satisfaction, even comparing with physical health services. Therefore, this study aimed to compare patient-reported quality between inpatient services for mental and physical health in China.MethodsAn inpatient survey was conducted among service users of mental and physical health services. Patient-reported quality was measured by the responsiveness performance questionnaire after patient discharge and based on patients' multiple experiences of hospitalization in the past 3 years. Chi-square tests were performed to compare the two patient groups' ratings on inpatient services for mental and physical health, and multivariate logistic regression was performed to adjust covariates in the group comparison.ResultsInpatient services for mental health were rated better than those for physical health on “treating with respect” (AOR = 3.083, 95% CI = 1.102–8.629) and “choosing a healthcare provider” (AOR = 2.441, 95% CI = 1.263–4.717). However, mental health services had poorer ratings on “asking patient's opinions” (AOR = 0.485, 95% CI = 0.259–0.910). For other responsiveness items, no significant difference was detected between the two types of inpatient services.ConclusionMental health inpatient services provided by China's tertiary hospitals could perform as well as physical health inpatient services in most aspects and even better perform regarding dignity and choice of healthcare providers. However, neglecting patients' voices is more severe in inpatient services for mental health.

Understanding components and predictors of delay of first treatment for mental health problems: A hospital-based study in China

“…Without a strict referral system, patients in China could choose any healthcare provider they wish, even specialist services (Lu et al, 2019). When some patients or their family members could recognize the condition as a mental health problem, they would go seek mental health services directly (70.4% of our participants), without the procedure of referral by a primary healthcare provider/general practitioner (Zhou et al, 2023), which could largely reduce the proportions and duration of Delay-R.…”

Analysis of the impact of healthcare providers’ mental health on patient care

“…These studies have been mostly limited to medical students and interns, with few studies focusing on resident doctors. [7][8][9][10] Given limited data over healthcare professionals, especially in nursing services from India and growing mental health problems in the medical fraternity, there is a need to assess mental health issues. Improving the understanding of mental health issues can help in amending the policies.…”