A Comparison of Neighbourhood Selection Techniques in Spatio-Temporal Forecasting Models

Abstract

ABSTRACT:Spatio-temporal neighbourhood (STN) selection is an important part of the model building procedure in spatio-temporal forecasting. The STN can be defined as the set of observations at neighbouring locations and times that are relevant for forecasting the future values of a series at a particular location at a particular time. Correct specification of the STN can enable forecasting models to capture spatio-temporal dependence, greatly improving predictive performance. In recent years, deficiencies have been revealed in models with globally fixed STN structures, which arise from the problems of heterogeneity, nonstationarity and nonlinearity in spatio-temporal processes. Using the example of a large dataset of travel times collected on London's road network, this study examines the effect of various STN selection methods drawn from the variable selection literature, varying from simple forward/backward subset selection to simultaneous shrinkage and selection operators. The results indicate that STN selection methods based on penalisation are effective. In particular, the maximum concave penalty (MCP) method selects parsimonious models that produce good forecasting performance.* Corresponding author. This is useful to know for communication with the appropriate person in cases with more than one author.

Spatio-Temporal Congestion Patterns in Urban Traffic Networks

“…(Gao, Sun, & Shi, 2011) apply a graphical Lasso approach. (Haworth & Cheng, 2014) give a comparison about different techniques. However, those are still based on a link level approach.…”

Feature selection and extraction in spatiotemporal traffic forecasting: a systematic literature review

“…Kamarianakis et al [51] applied LASSO to vector autoregressive models; Piatkowski et al [52] utilised LASSO and elastic net techniques to construct a graphical (random field) model; Li et al [53] and Zhou et al [54] executed preliminary feature selection and constructed LASSO-regularised autoregressive distributed lag models. Haworth and Cheng [55] analysed alternative regularisation techniques, maximum concave penalty (MCP) and smoothly clipped absolute deviation (SCAD), and found MCP beneficial with respect to the estimated STN sparsity.…”