A Comparative Study of Strategies for Sustainable Development of Multifunctional Fen Landscapes: Signposts to Explore New Avenues

Abstract

The present study comparatively analyses local and supra-local strategies for sustainable development of multifunctional fen landscapes in Germany (five strategies), the Netherlands (six strategies) and the UK (seven strategies)-thereby filling a gap in the existing academic literature. Fen landscapes have a peat soil which may be irreversibly lost once decomposed. These landscapes are currently under pressure due to drainage and land-use changes. A variety of strategies is applied and no particular type of strategy dominates in efforts to achieve sustainability. Such variety may be explained by differences in national policy contexts, decision-making and designing traditions, and, views on urgency and priorities of sustainability issues. Yet, the landscapes of our research focus exist in the organized mutual context of the European Union. Our study provides essential characteristics of steering interventions, to be considered by European policy-makers, when supporting initiatives for sustainable development of these landscapes. These include: focus on slowing down peat loss by reserving about 20-30% of an area for rewetting and/or nature conservation; development of a long-term vision; facilitation of a fair, transparent, inclusive and careful negotiation process on goals, means and sacrifices.

Evaluating governance for sustainable development – Insights from experiences in the Dutch fen landscape

“…An environment heavily shaped by human activity, the Dutch fen landscape is a prime example of a multi-actor, multi-sector and multi-level challenge with a biophysical and socio-economic situation characterised by complexities and uncertainties. The landscape is characterised by high population density, intensive economic usage, high pressure on spatial usage and natural resources, conflicting claims by involved groups and involvement of numerous governmental bodies (Den Uyl and Wassen, 2013). The sustainability challenge of this landscape affects public and private stakeholders at local and regional scale, includes a complicated technical assignment for water management, and involves several types of land-uses.…”