A comparative study of fluorescent microscopy with Ziehl-Neelsen staining and culture for the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis

Abstract

Background: For developing countries with a large number of cases and financial constraints, evaluation of rapid and inexpensive diagnostic methods has great importance. The bacilli in the sputum can be detected microscopically by ZN stain and fluorochrome stain. Objectives : To study the efficacy of fluorescence microscopy in the diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis in comparison to Ziehl-Neelsen staining and culture of sputum samples from patients suspected of pulmonary tuberculosis. Materials and methods : 306 sputum samples collected from 102 patients suspected of pulmonary tuberculosis were processed by the Petroff's method, and subjected to Ziehl-Neelsen staining (ZN), fluorescent Auramine-O staining (AO) and culture on modified Lowenstein-Jensen media (gold standard) for detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Positive smears were graded according to Forbes BA et al, and culture isolates were biochemically tested for confirmation of species. Results : Out of 102 patients, 44.1%, 71.6% and 70% were found positive by ZN, AO and culture respectively. AO was found to be superior to ZN on several aspects. The difference in their case detection rates was statistically significant (χ2 = 24.93, p < 0.001). AO was also able to detect more pauci-bacillary cases than ZN. There was more agreement between culture and fluorescence microscopy (95.1%) than with ZN microscopy (69.6%). The percentage of false negative by AO staining was only 2.78% which was in sharp contrast to that of ZN (40.27%). Conclusion: The better case detection rates of AO over ZN were comparable to those found by several studies. Since screening was done under lower power of magnification (400x), fluorescence microscopy has been found to be less time consuming as compared to ZN method (1000x) in the diagnosis of tuberculosis. The tubercle bacilli stood out as bright objects against a dark background in fluorescence microscopy which makes them easily identifiable hence causing less eye-strain. The efficacy of fluorescence microscopy proved to be much higher than conventional light microscopy and comparable to that of culture. Key words: Ziehl-Neelsen staining; Mycobacterium tuberculosis; Auramine-O DOI: 10.3126/kumj.v7i3.2728 Kathmandu University Medical Journal (2009) Vol.7, No.3 Issue 27, 226-230

Diagnostic performance of fluorescent light‐emitting diode microscopy for tuberculous lymphadenitis in a high‐burden setting

“…Lower specificity of LED microscopy compared with conventional ZN microscopy has been reported previously . Most studies found that the specificity of LED microscopy was comparable with that of conventional ZN microscopy. In the present study, the specificity of LED microscopy was slightly lower than that of ZN microscopy, but the difference was not statistically significant.…”

Enhanced Diagnostic Yield of Auramine-O Staining and Mycobacteria Growth Indicator Tube Over Ziehl-Neelsen Staining and Lowenstein Jensen Media in Extra-Pulmonary Tuberculosis

“…However, the standard method of sputum examination, that is, ZN staining is not sensitive enough and a large number of these suspected cases miss diagnosis. [5] It is of particular importance in the diagnosis of extrapulmonary disease, in which the acid fast bacilli are present in scanty number or may not be detected at all. Hence, ZN staining alone cannot be relied upon for the diagnosis of tuberculosis.…”

A Comparative Study of Sputum Smears by Ziehl Neelsen Staining Versus Fluorescent Staining in the Diagnosis of Pulmonary Tuberculosis in Patients Suffering With Cough for 2 Weeks or More

“…6. FM can diagnose more number of Pauci bacillary TB than ZN microscopy (7) so it helps in early diagnosis of TB, reducing the complications of TB such as Post Tubercular Bronchiectasis, fibrosis, haemoptysis, Aspergillosis, BPF, Broncholith, Cavernolith and scar carcinoma. 7.…”