Chromatin undergoes a dramatic reorganization during the cell cycle 1-3 . In interphase, chromatin is organized into compartments and topological-associating domains (TADs) that are cell-type specific 4-7 , whereas in metaphase, chromosomes undergo large-scale compaction, leading to the loss of specific boundaries and the shutdown of transcription [8][9][10][11][12] . Loop extrusion by structural maintenance of chromosomes complexes (SMCs) has been proposed as a mechanism to organize chromatin in interphase and metaphase [13][14][15][16][17][18][19] . However, the requirements for chromatin organization in these cell phases are very different, and it is unknown whether loop extrusion dynamics and the complexes that extrude them also differ. Here, we used Xenopus egg extracts to reconstitute and image loop extrusion of single DNA molecules during the cell cycle. We show that loops form in both metaphase and interphase, but with distinct dynamic properties. Condensin extrudes asymmetric loops in metaphase, whereas cohesin extrudes symmetric loops in interphase. Our data show that loop extrusion is a general mechanism for the organization of DNA, with dynamic and structural properties that are molecularly regulated during the cell cycle.
Main text:To visualize loop formation in Xenopus laevis egg extracts, we attached lambdaphage DNA to a cover slip using biotin-streptavidin linkers 20 in a custom-built microfluidic chamber (Fig. 1A). Addition of either metaphase-arrested or interphase Xenopus egg extracts into the chamber triggered the formation of small DNA enrichments, consistent with nucleosomal deposition 21,22 , that rapidly reduced any slack in the DNA molecules ( Fig. S1A and Movies 1-2). To allow enough slack for the formation of loops, we abolished nucleosomal assembly along the strand by depleting ~90-95% of soluble H3-H4 heterodimers in the extract 23 (Fig. S1B). This led to the formation of compacted DNA clusters that grew in size over time both in metaphase and interphase extracts ( Fig. 1B and Movies 3-8). To investigate whether these clusters exhibit a topology consistent with DNA loops, we applied hydrodynamic forces to the DNA strand by introducing a flow in the perpendicular direction to the strand. This procedure revealed DNA clusters with a characteristic loop topology similar to loop extrusion by yeast condensin in vitro 24 (Fig. 1C, Fig. S1C and Movie 9-12). In mock-depleted extracts, loops also formed but at a much lower frequency ( Fig. S1D and Movie 13) and seemed to compete with nucleosomes for free DNA. These results show that single DNA loop extrusion can be reconstituted in Xenopus egg extracts in metaphase and interphase.Current theoretical models propose that SMCs organize chromatin by extruding symmetric DNA loops 14,16,18 . However, recent experimental studies have shown that yeast condensin can extrude loops asymmetrically in vitro 24 . Although this supports the loop-extrusion hypothesis, it is inconsistent with the symmetric extrusion predicted by theory 25,26 . One reason for ...