“…Gabii, a central Italian polity that emerged chronologically and geographically alongside Rome (Figure 1), is presented in ancient literary sources as a canonical example of urban decline, and both implicitly and explicitly portrayed as a failure when compared with Rome (Becker et al 2009). Intentionally stepping outside of this model, we use a 'rhythmic' approach (Lefebvre 2004) to interpret the material record uncovered by a decade of archaeological excavations at Gabii (Mogetta & Becker 2014;Fabbri & Musco 2016;Samuels et al 2021; for preliminary data from the Gabii Project, see https://gabii.cast.uark.edu/data). In this, we problematise linear models that assume a connection between growth in settlement extent and urban success, and between reduction in size and urban failure.…”