A Cambodian smallholder farmer's choice between microfinance institutes and informal commercial moneylenders: the role of risk attitude

Abstract

PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to examine the extent to which individual risk attitude determines a Cambodian smallholder's choice between a commercial informal loan and a credit from a licensed microfinance institution.Design/methodology/approachThe paper analyzes a sample of smallholder farmers in the Ratanakiri province in northeastern Cambodia, a country with a long history of microfinance and a saturated microcredit market. Employing a binary and a multinomial logit model, this paper assesses the effect of individual risk attitude on the choice of a financial instrument.FindingsThe results reveal a statistically significant relationship between the choice of a credit source and an individual's risk attitude: On average (c.p.) the less risk averse the smallholder is, the more they tend to prefer an unlicensed commercial lender.Practical implicationsThe findings suggest that less risk-averse individuals tend to take up riskier and generally more expensive informal loans. Measures to increase the safe access to financial services for less risk-averse borrowers as well as improvements in financial literacy should be undertaken to protect smallholders from taking risky choices.Originality/valueAlthough existing studies have examined the importance of risk attitudes between credit provider and borrower, they focus mainly on the lender's perspective. This paper provides new insights on how risk attitude influences the borrower's choice in Cambodia. Thus, this study is relevant for policymakers in countries with oversaturated microcredit markets and a high prevalence of informal lenders.

Is Loan Shark an Alternative? The Intentions to Take a Loan from Loan Sharks in Indonesia

“…Research found that people are more attracted to loan sharks due to their flexibility in providing the services and has even reduced the demand for institutional credit (Ray, 2019). Taking loans from loan sharks was driven by community knowledge of the low risk they will receive (Possner et al, 2022) or failure to access banking (Scaglione, 2014). Loan sharks continue to have their existence in society (Venittelli, 2021).…”

“…Small farmers in Cambodia are more likely to use the services offered even though the interest rates were high if they are unaware of the dangers of borrowing from loan sharks (Possner et al, 2022). Another study conducted by Ray revealed that in rural Indian communities, the flexibility provided by loan sharks services had appeared as an attractive point that made the services more preferred by the community (Ray, 2019).…”

“…Previous studies showed that little has been done to examine the micro and macro effects of loan sharking on society (Possner et al, 2022;Ray, 2019;Scaglione, 2014). According to previous studies, people who interact with loan sharks as the sharia economy develops because of the services they receive, word-of-mouth, and subjective norms within their communities.…”

The role of risk rationing in rural credit demand and uptake: lessons from Kyrgyzstan

“…Instead, farmers seeking credit are likely to turn to the informal sectors offering low-collateral loans at high interest rates; as pointed out by Binswanger and Silas (1983), risk-averse individuals prefer high interest over collateral requirements to avoid high additional costs at the default stage. Possner et al (2021) analyzed Cambodian smallholders' credit demand and found that less risk-averse individuals tend to take up riskier and generally more expensive informal loans. Beyond risk attitude, actual or perceived risk can also influence the demand for credit.…”

RENTENIR: Alternatif Kredit Bagi Pedagang Muslim Di Kota Langsa Pada Masa Pandemi COVID-19

“…Problematika rentenir tidak hanya terjadi di Kota Langsa, bahkan di berbagai negara juga mengalami kasus yang sama terkait dengan permasalahan rentenir, seperti penelitian Annkathrin Possner, Selina Bruns dan Oliver Musshoff yang dilakukan di negara Kamboja (Possner et al, 2021) mengambarkan bahwa para petani kecil memilih rentenir sebagai kreditur karena sedikit resiko. Penelitian Bruce R. Bolnick di Malawi (Bolnick, 1992), Claudia N. Berg, M. Shahe Emran dan Forhad Shilpi di Banglades (Berg et al, 2013) dan penelitian Louise Signal, Tolotea Lanumata, Sharron Bowers di New Zealand (Signal et al, 2012a).…”