The adsorption behavior of cinchona-type chiral modifiers (β-isocinchonine, cinchonidine, and cinchonine)
on model rhodium and platinum catalysts has been studied using attenuated total reflection infrared (ATR-IR) spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT). The ATR-IR studies performed under conditions closely
resembling those encountered during enantioselective hydrogenation as well as in the absence of hydrogen
revealed significant differences in the adsorption mode of the modifiers, depending on the rotational flexibility
of the modifier, the platinum group metal, and the presence of hydrogen. The more rigid β-isocinchonine
showed preferential tilted adsorption on both metals, independent of the presence or absence of hydrogen.
Cinchonidine and cinchonine were adsorbed on Pt predominantly with the quinoline ring nearly parallel to
the surface, irrespective of the presence or absence of hydrogen, whereas on Rh in the presence of hydrogen
only tilted species were observed. The latter behavior is attributed to the fast hydrogenation of the aromatic
anchoring group (quinoline) on Rh that interferes with the adsorption process. DFT calculations confirmed
that the energy difference between tilted and adsorbed species decreases in the case of the β-isocinchonine.
This combined spectroscopic and theoretical investigation indicates a greater bias toward the tilting of the
anchoring group in the case of β-iCN as compared to the natural occurring alkaloids cinchonidine and
cinchonine. Such behavior explains the greater stability toward quinoline ring saturation observed for
β-isocinchonine on rhodium-supported catalysts during enantioselective hydrogenation. This study thus helps
define the delicate equilibrium between formation of chiral surface sites and their stability in strongly reducing
conditions in terms of the structure and consequent adsorption behavior of the modifier molecule, as a function
of the metal catalyst of choice.