Recent efforts to estimate the number of modes sufficient for the approximate solutions of Navier-Stokes equations in two dimensions are summarized. Several such estimates have been obtained, and their relations to one another are discussed. The physical significance of the results is noted and used to infer the possible nature of similar estimates in three dimensions.PACS numbers: 03.40. Gc, 47.10.+g, An important unsolved issue in the numerical simulation of fluid flows is the a priori estimate of the number of modes or the number of mesh points needed to obtain correct approximate solutions to the Navier-Stokes equation. The importance of this question lies in (a) the proliferation of published numerical results, and (b) the clear evidence that the qualitative behavior of the approximate solutions (to say nothing of their quantitative behavior) may depend critically on the number of modes retained, for instance, in the Galerkin approximation. 1 ' 2 In this Letter we summarize some recent efforts to determine the sufficient number of modes needed for the approximate solutions of Navier-Stokes equations in two dimensions; we discuss the physical significance of the results and show how they may perhaps be extended to three dimensions; finally we discuss briefly the connection with other related efforts.As is well known, there are estimates of the necessary number of modes for isotropic, homogeneous, fully developed turbulence-they are based on the Kolmogorov length in three dimensions, 3 and on the enstrophy dissipation length in two dimensions. 4 However, it is not clear that such estimates are sufficient, nor how to extend them to anisotropic, inhomogeneous flows of fluids. Thus it is useful to explore the asymptotic properties (i.e., for large times) of the Navier-Stokes equations with a view to establishing a bound for the sufficient number of modes determining an adequate approximation to its true solutions.A relevant asymptotic property is given by the following result 5 : Consider the Navier-Stokes equation in a two-dimensional region fi,where v=(v 19 v 2 ) is the fluid velocity, p is the kinematic pressure, v is the viscosity, T(r 9 t) is the externally imposed force per unit mass, and we have assumed the fluid density to be constant, say, unity. We supplement (1) with the boundary condition v = 0on the boundary a£2, or, if Q is a rectangle, with periodic conditions on v. Associated with (1) and the appropriate boundary conditions is the Stokes problem:where q is determined uniquely by (2). The vector-valued eigenfunctions of (2) may be used as a basis for an expansion of v, i.e.,
v(?,o=:sc«fc)w,(f). o) i=lLet Xj be the eigenvalue belonging to w i? such that 0