“…In our opinion, the physical mechanism underlying pulse formation in this system is the interaction between the counterpropagating pulses that is at work in colliding-pulse mode-locked lasers (see e.g., [17]), which is based on the ultrafast dynamics of the gain in active semiconductor systems as described in [18]. This same mechanism is, in our opinion, the one that leads to active ML by counterpropagating injection of external pulses, as, for example, in [9,10,19,20].…”