Perceived inequity, professional and personal fulfillment by women intensivists in France

Abstract

Background The medical workforce has been feminized for the last two decades worldwide. Nonetheless, women remain under-represented among intensivists. We conducted a survey among French women intensivists to assess their professional and personal quality of life and their perception of potential gender discrimination at work. Methods We conducted an observational descriptive study by sending a survey, designed by the group FEMMIR (FEmmes Médecins en Médecine Intensive Réanimation), to women intensivists in France, using primarily the Société de Réanimation de Langue Française (SRLF) mailing list. The questionnaire was also available online between September 2019 and January 2020 and women intensivists were encouraged to answer through email reminders. It pertained to five main domains, including demographic characteristics, work position, workload and clinical/research activities, self-fulfillment scale, perceived discrimination at work and suggested measures to implement. Results Three hundred and seventy-one women responded to the questionnaire, among whom 16% had an academic position. Being a woman intensivist and pregnancy were both considered to increase difficulties in careers’ advancement by 31% and 73% of the respondents, respectively. Almost half of the respondents (46%) quoted their quality of life equal to or lower than 6 on a scale varying from 1 (very bad quality of life) to 10 (excellent quality of life). They were 52% to feel an imbalance between their personal and professional life at the cost of their personal life. Gender discrimination has been experienced by 55% of the respondents while 37% confided having already been subject of bullying or harassment. Opportunities to adjust their work timetable including part-time work, better considerations for pregnant women including increasing the number of intensivists and the systematic replacement during maternity leave, and the respect of the law regarding the paternity leave were suggested as key measures to enable better professional and personal accomplishment by women intensivists. Conclusion In this first large French survey in women intensivists, we pointed out issues felt by women intensivists that included an imbalance between professional and personal life, a perceived loss of opportunity due to the fact of being a woman, frequent reported bullying or harassment and a lack of consideration of the needs related to pregnancy and motherhood.

Gender disparity in critical care publications: a novel Female First Author Index

“…Women are under-represented in critical care training programs, attending/consultant positions, academic faculty, as well as positions of leadership [ 1 ]. A majority of women critical care medicine faculty are shown to be personally or professionally impacted by gender inequality [ 2 , 3 ]. This gender inequality manifests on medical panels, task force participation, guideline publications, conferences and in editorial board positions [ 4 ].…”

Gender Bias and the Lack of Equity in Pandemic Nursing in China: A Qualitative Study

“…The passive gender schema is integrated into the entire external environment that is unfavorable to women. Studies have shown that the reasons for women’s career barriers in the workplace are believed to be psychological factors such as dependency and obedience [ 32 ]. Therefore, women are also labeled as sensitive and fragile, not strong enough, lacking the spirit of hardship, and generally unable to withstand high pressure in management positions [ 46 ].…”

“…Similarly, in a traditional hierarchical medical environment, there is concern that a culture of bullying is acceptable at the lower levels of the pyramid. In addition, female nurses who have just started work are subject not only to gender bias, but also to vertical workplace bullying [32][33][34]. If allowed to continue, these behaviors create a culture of distrust and fear of retribution and contribute to high turnover rates in many institutions.…”

Female representation in intensive care medicine: Challenges and perspectives from China

“…[3] Hence, many efforts have been made to improve the current situation. [4] , [5] In China, the number of female ICU physicians has been increasing in recent years. The biggest challenges female ICU physicians face include maintaining a work–life balance, impediments in career planning, and lack of academic influence.…”