A New Phenotyping Pipeline Reveals Three Types of Lateral Roots and a Random Branching Pattern in Two Cereals

Abstract

Recent progress in root phenotyping has focused mainly on increasing throughput for genetic studies, while identifying root developmental patterns has been comparatively underexplored. We introduce a new phenotyping pipeline for producing high-quality spatiotemporal root system development data and identifying developmental patterns within these data. The SmartRoot image-analysis system and temporal and spatial statistical models were applied to two cereals, pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum) and maize (Zea mays). Semi-Markov switching linear models were used to cluster lateral roots based on their growth rate profiles. These models revealed three types of lateral roots with similar characteristics in both species. The first type corresponds to fast and accelerating roots, the second to rapidly arrested roots, and the third to an intermediate type where roots cease elongation after a few days. These types of lateral roots were retrieved in different proportions in a maize mutant affected in auxin signaling, while the first most vigorous type was absent in maize plants exposed to severe shading. Moreover, the classification of growth rate profiles was mirrored by a ranking of anatomical traits in pearl millet. Potential dependencies in the succession of lateral root types along the primary root were then analyzed using variable-order Markov chains. The lateral root type was not influenced by the shootward neighbor root type or by the distance from this root. This random branching pattern of primary roots was remarkably conserved, despite the high variability of root systems in both species. Our phenotyping pipeline opens the door to exploring the genetic variability of lateral root developmental patterns. Breakthrough Technologieswww.plantphysiol.org on April 29, 2019 -Published by Downloaded from

Three-Dimensional Time-Lapse Analysis Reveals Multiscale Relationships in Maize Root Systems with Contrasting Architectures

“…Another important caveat of twodimensional (2D) growth systems is that once architectures become large and complex enough for roots to occlude one another, the ability to track the growth of individual roots is greatly diminished and usually unfeasible if grown in soil because the topology is obscured. A recent optical imaging study quantifying lateral root development in millet and maize growing in hydroponic 2D rhizotrons reported an average of 2-d-per-plant processing time using a state-of-the-art semi-automated root tracing tool (Passot et al, 2018). Hence, intense interest in X-ray and magnetic resonance-based 3D imaging for root studies has been warranted (Mooney et al, 2012;Helliwell et al, 2013;Roose et al, 2016;Morris et al, 2017).…”

Development of a model estimating root length density from root impacts on a soil profile in pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum(L.) R. Br). Application to measure root system response to water stress in field conditions

“…The growth of these roots was more or less horizontal in shallow soils and became more and more vertical with increased depth. Conversely, the growth orientation of fine roots, which most likely corresponded to the different types of laterals [13 and 26], was only marginally dependent on soil depth. This led us to develop a model for RLD estimation that considered soil depth as an important variable.…”

Maize lateral root developmental plasticity induced by mild water stress. II: Genotype‐specific spatio‐temporal effects on determinate development

“…To investigate the dynamics of the increase in individual root elongation, lengths of the 10 longest laterals were assessed throughout the 11-day experiments. In previous studies, large variability in both length and elongation rate has been observed among lateral roots in maize (Cahn et al, 1989;Moreno-Ortega et al, 2017;Passot et al, 2018) and other species (Freixes, Thibaud, Tardieu, & Muller, 2002;Muller et al, 2019;Pagès, 1995). F I G U R E 1 Average length of FR697 (a) and B73 (b) primary (black and red) and seminal (blue and orange) axial roots during 11 days after transplanting (DAT) to well-watered (WW) conditions (black and blue) or a mild water deficit (MWD) treatment at a transplant Ψ w of −0.28 MPa (red and orange).…”

“…In the MWD treatment, in contrast, the genotypes exhibited strongly divergent responses from 4 DAT. Whereas the growth pattern of B73 roots was very similar under WW and MWD conditions throughout the experiments (Figure 3b We selected the 10 longest roots, which exhibited maximum elongation rates that were similar to those of the fastest-growing category characterized previously (Moreno-Ortega et al, 2017;Passot et al, 2018). However, the growth duration exhibited in both FR697…”