Participants’ Perceptions on the Use of Wearable Devices to Reduce Sitting Time: Qualitative Analysis

Abstract

BackgroundRecent epidemiological evidence indicates that, on average, people are sedentary for approximately 7.7 hours per day. There are deleterious effects of prolonged sedentary behavior that are separate from participation in physical activity and include increased risk of weight gain, cancer, metabolic syndrome, diabetes, and heart disease. Previous trials have used wearable devices to increase physical activity in studies; however, additional research is needed to fully understand how this technology can be used to reduce sitting time.ObjectiveThe purpose of this study was to explore the potential of wearable devices as an intervention tool in a larger sedentary behavior study through a general inductive and deductive analysis of focus group discussions.MethodsWe conducted four focus groups with 15 participants to discuss 7 different wearable devices with sedentary behavior capabilities. Participants recruited for the focus groups had previously participated in a pilot intervention targeting sedentary behavior over a 3-week period and were knowledgeable about the challenges of reducing sitting time. During the focus groups, participants commented on the wearability, functionality, and feedback mechanism of each device and then identified their two favorite and two least favorite devices. Finally, participants designed and described their ideal or dream wearable device. Two researchers, who have expertise analyzing qualitative data, coded and analyzed the data from the focus groups. A thematic analysis approach using Dedoose software (SocioCultural Research Consultants, LLC version 7.5.9) guided the organization of themes that reflected participants’ perspectives.ResultsAnalysis resulted in 14 codes that we grouped into themes. Three themes emerged from our data: (1) features of the device, (2) data the device collected, and (3) how data are displayed.ConclusionsCurrent wearable devices for increasing physical activity are insufficient to intervene on sitting time. This was especially evident when participants voted, as several participants reported using a “process of elimination” as opposed to choosing favorites because none of the devices were ideal for reducing sitting time. To overcome the limitations in current devices, future wearable devices designed to reduce sitting time should include the following features: waterproof, long battery life, accuracy in measuring sitting time, real time feedback on progress toward sitting reduction goals, and flexible options for prompts to take breaks from sitting.

Diet and Activity Assessments and Interventions Using Technology in Older Adults

“…53 In a focus group with older adults around technology, the accountability of a human was important. 110 Human coaches can provide these important behavior change strategies in complement with technology. To date, no studies have directly compared wearable devices alone with wearable devices plus health coaching in general older adult populations, but there is strong evidence of the effectiveness of health coaching in other populations.…”

Wearable Technology in Higher Education Reform

“…Wearable devices have the characteristics of smaller space requirements and low power consumption, and can allow automatic capture of data [19][20][21], while interacting with the environment. Users can wear wearable devices with them, such as watches, glasses, helmet, backpack and so on.…”

Feedback on Physical Activity Through a Wearable Device Connected to a Mobile Phone App in Patients With Metabolic Syndrome: Pilot Study

“…However, the data collected by the wearable devices are rarely integrated into the programming of regimens for impaired metabolic conditions. Moreover, evidence supporting the sustained use of data derived from wearable devices or their positive effects on health outcomes is lacking as most studies have mainly focused on establishing the feasibility of the devices and the association between measured physical activity and short-term benefits [8-10]. Recent research indicates that feedback on activity monitoring can successfully increase physical activity levels and lead to beneficial outcomes in the management of target diseases [11].…”