Barriers and enablers to skin-to-skin contact at birth in healthy neonates - a qualitative study

Abstract

BackgroundSkin to skin contact (SSC) at birth is the standard of care for newborns without risk factors. However, implementation of SSC at birth has been far from optimal. A qualitative study was undertaken to determine the barriers, enablers and potential solutions to implementation of SSC at birth in healthy newborn infants in a level III neonatal-care facility in Bangalore, India.MethodsConsultants and residents/postgraduates (PG) from the departments of Obstetrics (n = 19) and Pediatrics (n = 14) and nurses (n = 8) in the labor room (LR) participated in the study. In depth interviews (IDI) and focus group discussions (FGD) were carried out with an interview guide and a moderators’ guide containing inbuilt probes. Subjects of FGD were homogenous. All IDI and FGD were audio-taped, transcribed and analyzed using N VIVO version 9 (using free and tree nodes). Two authors separately coded the transcripts. Major and minor themes were identified. Rigor was ensured by triangulation and theoretical saturation. Informed consent and ethical approval was obtained.ResultsAll subjects were aware of SSC at birth, some of its benefits and had practiced SSC. The major barriers identified were lack of personnel (nurses), time constraint, difficulty in deciding on eligibility for SSC, safety concerns, interference with clinical routines, and interdepartmental issues. Recall of an adverse event during SSC was also a major barrier. Furthermore, we found that most participants considered 1 h as impractical; and promoted 5–15 min SSC. Minor themes were gender bias of the newborn and cultural practices.The participants offered solutions such as assigning a helper exclusively for SSC, allowing a family member into the LR, continuing SSC after initial routines, antenatal counselling, constant reminders in the form of periodic sessions with audiovisual aids or posters in the obstetrics ward, training of new nurses and PG, and inclusion of SSC in medical and nursing curriculum.ConclusionsThe major barriers to SSC at birth are lack of personnel, time constraint and safety concerns. Training, designated health personnel for SSC and teamwork are the key interventions likely to improve SSC at birth.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12887-018-1033-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Prevalence and determinants of mother and newborn skin-to-skin contact in The Gambia: a secondary data analysis

“…In several SSA countries, mother and newborn SSC is rarely practiced [ 17 ], because mothers do not view SSC as important for keeping the baby warm after birth since newborns are usually taking away from their mothers immediately after birth, also due to prevailing cultural beliefs and practices that discourage mother and newborn SSC [ 18 – 20 ]. Moreover, health providers’ factors such as lack of skilled personnel and time constraint, lack of awareness of the practice and its benefit have accounted for low coverage of mother and newborn SSC [ 21 ]. Very low rates were reported in Tanzania (less than 1%) [ 22 ], Uganda and Mali (2% each) [ 23 , 24 ], Nigeria (10%) [ 25 ], Ghana, (10%) [ 20 ], and in Ethiopia (9% and 13%) [ 26 , 27 ].…”

Nurses’ Kangaroo Mother Care practice implementation and future challenges: an integrative review

“…Nurses play a crucial role in promoting this practice to address newborn development in healthcare practice . This role requires nurses to maintain and adhere to quality standards, which are supported by higher management authorities .…”

“…However, despite the findings of several research studies, the approaches in addressing solutions and strategies for each KMC barrier remain unclear. Subsequently, some studies on the barriers and KMC practices of nurses focus mainly on neonatal intensive care units (NICU), which vary from one hospital to another . Existing studies did not investigate the KMC challenges encountered by nurses in clinical settings.…”

Vivências de mulheres com o parto domiciliar: resgate por meio da história oral

“…21 Conquanto, mesmo que conhecidos os seus benefícios de tal ação para a mãe e bebê, não se trata de uma prática realizada universalmente. 22 Constatou-se neste estudo, que a atuação das parteiras foi expressa de forma positiva pelas participantes, à semelhança de outras pesquisas. 15,23 Essa percepção pode decorrer do atendimento diferenciado fornecido pelas parteiras, 15…”