Experiences of pressure to conform in postgraduate medical education

Abstract

BackgroundPerception of pressure to conform prevents learners from actively participating in educational encounters. We expected that residents would report experiencing different amounts of pressure to conform in a variety of educational settings.MethodsA total of 166 residents completed questionnaires about the frequency of conformity pressure they experience across 14 teaching and clinical settings. We examined many individual characteristics such as their age, sex, international student status, level of education, and tolerance of ambiguity; and situational characteristics such as residency program, type of learning session, status of group members, and type of rotation to determine when conformity pressure is most likely to occur.ResultsThe majority of participants (89.8%) reported pressure to conform at least sometimes in at least one educational or clinical setting. Residents reported higher rates of conformity during informal, rather than formal, teaching sessions, p < .001. Also, pressure was greater when residents interacted with higher status group members, but not with the same or lower level status members, p < .001. Effect sizes were in the moderate range.ConclusionsThe findings suggest that most residents do report feeling pressure to conform in their residency settings. This result is consistent with observations of medical students, nursing students, and clerks conforming in response to inaccurate information within experimental studies. Perception of pressure is associated with the setting rather than the trainee personal characteristics.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12909-017-1108-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

To disclose or not to disclose? Peer workers impact on a culture of safe disclosure for mental health professionals with lived experience.

“…Some mental health professionals expressed a belief that everyone should have opportunity to be a “dissenting voice” but they did not feel mental health professionals had this opportunity, whereas peers did. It is possible that non-designated roles, bound by greater restriction and mandated activity, produce a workforce that is more likely to conform than contest (Grendar et al, 2018; Levett-Jones & Lathlean, 2009). Further research could provide a more understanding of whether people in non-designated roles provide a less disruptive way for organizations to include lived experience perspectives and the reasons behind preferences.…”

<p>Prevalence and associated factors of depression and anxiety among doctoral students: the mediating effect of mentoring relationships on the association between research self-efficacy and depression/anxiety</p>

“…Students in medical schools engage in rigorous medical training. 24 , 25 Previous studies have demonstrated that medical students have more pressure, more burnout, and a greater prevalence of mental health disorders than the general population or students in other disciplines. 26 – 31 Medical training varies considerably by discipline, institution, and country.…”

Strengths and Challenges for Medical Students and Residents in Rural Japan

“…As learners did not discuss their learning with their teachers effectively, the learning situation might have led them to become passive learners. 15 This study found that the learning context did not encourage students to participate actively in patient care; they mostly learned by observing and emulating senior doctors. Clinical situations in universities and tertiary hospitals can incorporate medical students and residents into their medical teams and gradually demonstrate the processes of clinical reasoning through learners' active participation.…”