Accounting for the role of hematocrit in between‐subject variations of MRI‐derived baseline cerebral hemodynamic parameters and functional BOLD responses
Abstract:Baseline hematocrit fraction (Hct) is a determinant for baseline cerebral blood flow (CBF) and between-subject variation of Hct thus causes variation in task-based BOLD fMRI signal changes. We first verified in healthy volunteers (n 5 12) that Hct values can be derived reliably from venous blood T 1 values by comparison with the conventional lab test. Together with CBF measured using phase-contrast MRI, this noninvasive estimation of Hct, instead of using a population-averaged Hct value, enabled more individua… Show more
“…The results suggest that it is possible that previous studies of sex differences in functional connectivity that did not control for haemoglobin may be confounded, at least in ageing (e.g., Jamadar et al, 2018). Our results are consistent with some (Xu et al;Guensch et al, 2016), but not other (Yang et al) results in healthy younger adults. Given the differences in haemoglobin concentration over the lifespan (Backman et al 2016, Cruikshank, 1970Salive et al, 1992), future studies should explore if the effect of haemoglobin on the BOLD-fMRI signal varies with age.…”
Section: Discussionsupporting
confidence: 84%
“…The current sample is substantially larger than the previous studies of the influence of haemoglobin on BOLD-fMRI measures (Yang et al, 2015;Xu et al, 2018), with a sample size of 518 subjects. Like Xu et al (2018) our results suggest that individual differences in haemoglobin have a substantial influence on BOLD-fMRI measures of functional connectivity and functional connectivity-cognition relationships. In contrast to Yang et al (2015), we found that haemoglobin effects were widespread, spatially non-specific in men;…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 96%
“…In another sample of 13 healthy middle-aged (mean age 35yrs; s.d. 7) adults, Xu et al (2018) found that 22% (i.e., R 2 =0.22) of the inter-subject variability of the BOLD response in the visual cortex to flickering checkerboard stimulus was associated with haematocrit, consistent with previous studies of haematocrit and the BOLD signal (R 2 =0.23; Gustard et al, 2003; R 2 =0.28, Levin et al, 2001). When the BOLD response was normalised by the haematocrit, the BOLD signal coefficient of variation reduced by 16% leading Xu et al (2018) to conclude that normalisation of the BOLD signal by individual haematocrit levels is an important step for enhancing the detection power of BOLD-fMRI studies.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…This source of variability in BOLD signal (and SNR) across subjects has the potential to influence measures of functional connectivity, particularly for analyses that examine individual FC variability and differences between groups of individuals. In fact, inter-subject variation in haematocrit has been found to correlate with the degree of centrality of fMRI networks (Yang et al, 2015), and to mediate the magnitude of the BOLD response in the visual cortex (Xu et al, 2018).…”
Highlights:• Individual differences in haemoglobin significantly impact measures of functional connectivity in the elderly.• Significant differences in connectivity-cognition relationships are shown between groups separated by haemoglobin values without accompanying cognitive differences.• The influence of haemoglobin on functional connectivity differs between men and women.
Abstract:Resting-state connectivity measures the temporal coherence of the spontaneous neural activity of spatially distinct regions, and is commonly measured using BOLD-fMRI. The BOLD response follows neuronal activity, when changes in the relative concentration of oxygenated and deoxygenated haemoglobin cause fluctuations in the MRI T2* signal. Since the BOLD signal detects changes in relative concentrations of oxy/deoxy-haemoglobin, individual differences in haemoglobin levels may influence the BOLD signal-to-noise ratio in a manner independent of the degree of neural activity. In this study, we examined whether group differences in haemoglobin may confound measures of functional connectivity. We investigated whether relationships between measures of functional connectivity and cognitive performance could be influenced by individual variability in haemoglobin. Finally, we mapped the neuroanatomical distribution of the influence of haemoglobin on functional connectivity to determine where group differences in functional connectivity are manifest.In a cohort of 518 healthy elderly subjects (259 men) each sex group was median split into two groups with high and low haemoglobin concentration. Significant differences were obtained in functional connectivity between the high and low haemoglobin groups for both men and women (Cohen's d 0.17 and 0.03 for men and women respectively). The haemoglobin connectome in males showed a widespread systematic increase in functional connectivity correlational scores, whilst the female connectome showed predominantly parietal and subcortical increases and temporo-parietal decreases. Despite the haemoglobin groups having no differences in cognitive measures, significant differences in the linear relationships between cognitive performance and functional connectivity were obtained for all 5 cognitive tests in males, and 4 out of 5 tests in females.Our findings confirm that individual variability in haemoglobin levels that give rise to group differences are an important confounding variable in BOLD-fMRI-based studies of functional connectivity. Controlling for haemoglobin variability as a potentially confounding variable is crucial to ensure the reproducibility of human brain connectome studies, especially in studies that compare groups of individuals, compare sexes, or examine connectivity-cognition relationships.
“…The results suggest that it is possible that previous studies of sex differences in functional connectivity that did not control for haemoglobin may be confounded, at least in ageing (e.g., Jamadar et al, 2018). Our results are consistent with some (Xu et al;Guensch et al, 2016), but not other (Yang et al) results in healthy younger adults. Given the differences in haemoglobin concentration over the lifespan (Backman et al 2016, Cruikshank, 1970Salive et al, 1992), future studies should explore if the effect of haemoglobin on the BOLD-fMRI signal varies with age.…”
Section: Discussionsupporting
confidence: 84%
“…The current sample is substantially larger than the previous studies of the influence of haemoglobin on BOLD-fMRI measures (Yang et al, 2015;Xu et al, 2018), with a sample size of 518 subjects. Like Xu et al (2018) our results suggest that individual differences in haemoglobin have a substantial influence on BOLD-fMRI measures of functional connectivity and functional connectivity-cognition relationships. In contrast to Yang et al (2015), we found that haemoglobin effects were widespread, spatially non-specific in men;…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 96%
“…In another sample of 13 healthy middle-aged (mean age 35yrs; s.d. 7) adults, Xu et al (2018) found that 22% (i.e., R 2 =0.22) of the inter-subject variability of the BOLD response in the visual cortex to flickering checkerboard stimulus was associated with haematocrit, consistent with previous studies of haematocrit and the BOLD signal (R 2 =0.23; Gustard et al, 2003; R 2 =0.28, Levin et al, 2001). When the BOLD response was normalised by the haematocrit, the BOLD signal coefficient of variation reduced by 16% leading Xu et al (2018) to conclude that normalisation of the BOLD signal by individual haematocrit levels is an important step for enhancing the detection power of BOLD-fMRI studies.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…This source of variability in BOLD signal (and SNR) across subjects has the potential to influence measures of functional connectivity, particularly for analyses that examine individual FC variability and differences between groups of individuals. In fact, inter-subject variation in haematocrit has been found to correlate with the degree of centrality of fMRI networks (Yang et al, 2015), and to mediate the magnitude of the BOLD response in the visual cortex (Xu et al, 2018).…”
Highlights:• Individual differences in haemoglobin significantly impact measures of functional connectivity in the elderly.• Significant differences in connectivity-cognition relationships are shown between groups separated by haemoglobin values without accompanying cognitive differences.• The influence of haemoglobin on functional connectivity differs between men and women.
Abstract:Resting-state connectivity measures the temporal coherence of the spontaneous neural activity of spatially distinct regions, and is commonly measured using BOLD-fMRI. The BOLD response follows neuronal activity, when changes in the relative concentration of oxygenated and deoxygenated haemoglobin cause fluctuations in the MRI T2* signal. Since the BOLD signal detects changes in relative concentrations of oxy/deoxy-haemoglobin, individual differences in haemoglobin levels may influence the BOLD signal-to-noise ratio in a manner independent of the degree of neural activity. In this study, we examined whether group differences in haemoglobin may confound measures of functional connectivity. We investigated whether relationships between measures of functional connectivity and cognitive performance could be influenced by individual variability in haemoglobin. Finally, we mapped the neuroanatomical distribution of the influence of haemoglobin on functional connectivity to determine where group differences in functional connectivity are manifest.In a cohort of 518 healthy elderly subjects (259 men) each sex group was median split into two groups with high and low haemoglobin concentration. Significant differences were obtained in functional connectivity between the high and low haemoglobin groups for both men and women (Cohen's d 0.17 and 0.03 for men and women respectively). The haemoglobin connectome in males showed a widespread systematic increase in functional connectivity correlational scores, whilst the female connectome showed predominantly parietal and subcortical increases and temporo-parietal decreases. Despite the haemoglobin groups having no differences in cognitive measures, significant differences in the linear relationships between cognitive performance and functional connectivity were obtained for all 5 cognitive tests in males, and 4 out of 5 tests in females.Our findings confirm that individual variability in haemoglobin levels that give rise to group differences are an important confounding variable in BOLD-fMRI-based studies of functional connectivity. Controlling for haemoglobin variability as a potentially confounding variable is crucial to ensure the reproducibility of human brain connectome studies, especially in studies that compare groups of individuals, compare sexes, or examine connectivity-cognition relationships.
“…This finding is in good agreement with the report of Vernooij et al 6 It is well known that hematocrit fraction is a crucial determinant of CBF, and there exists an inverse relationship between hematocrit and CBF. 39 The normal hematocrit level ranges from 40-54% and from 36-48% for men and women, respectively. 40 The wide range of Hct among subjects may explain the larger intersubject variation of CBF.…”
Anemia is the most common blood disorder in the world. In patients with chronic anemia, such as sickle cell disease or major thalassemia, cerebral blood flow increases to compensate for decreased oxygen content. However, the effects of chronic anemia on oxygen extraction fraction (OEF) and cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen (CMRO 2 ) are less well understood. In this study, we examined 47 sickle-cell anemia subjects (age 21.7 ± 7.1, female 45%), 27 non-sickle anemic subjects (age 25.0 ± 10.4, female 52%) and 44 healthy controls (age 26.4 ± 10.6, female 71%) using MRI metrics of brain oxygenation and flow. Phase contrast MRI was used to measure resting cerebral blood flow, while T 2 -relaxation-under-spin-tagging (TRUST) MRI with disease appropriate calibrations were used to measure OEF and CMRO 2 . We observed that patients with sickle cell disease and other chronic anemias have decreased OEF and CMRO 2 (respectively 27.4 ± 4.1% and 3.39 ± 0.71 ml O 2 /100 g/ min in sickle cell disease, 30.8 ± 5.2% and 3.53 ± 0.64 ml O 2 /100 g/min in other anemias) compared to controls (36.7 ± 6.0% and 4.00 ± 0.65 ml O 2 /100 g/min). Impaired CMRO 2 was proportional to the degree of anemia severity. We further demonstrate striking concordance of the present work with pooled historical data from patients having broad etiologies for their anemia. The reduced cerebral oxygen extraction and metabolism are consistent with emerging data demonstrating increased non-nutritive flow, or physiological shunting, in sickle cell disease patients.Ms. Vu and Dr. Bush contributed equally and are designated as co-first authors.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.