Models for truth‐telling in physician‐patient encounters: What can we learn from Yoruba concept of Ooto?

Abstract

Empirical studies have now established that many patients make clinical decisions based on models other than Anglo American model of truth-telling and patient autonomy. Some scholars also add that current medical ethics frameworks and recent proposals for enhancing communication in health professional-patient relationship have not adequately accommodated these models. In certain clinical contexts where health professional and patients are motivated by significant cultural and religious values, these current frameworks cannot prevent communication breakdown, which can, in turn, jeopardize patient care, cause undue distress to a patient in certain clinical contexts or negatively impact his/her relationship with the community. These empirical studies have now recommended that additional frameworks developed around other models of truth-telling; and which take very seriously significant value-differences which sometimes exist between health professional and patients, as well as patient's cultural/religious values or relational capacities, must be developed. This paper contributes towards the development of one. Specifically, this study proposes a framework for truth-telling developed around African model of truth-telling by drawing insights from the communitarian concept of ootọ́ amongst the Yoruba people of south west Nigeria. I am optimistic that if this model is incorporated into current medical ethics codes and curricula, it will significantly enhance health professional-patient communication.

Parents’ and healthcare professionals’ experiences and perceptions of parental readiness for resuscitation in Iranian paediatric hospitals: a qualitative study

“…Preferences and values about access to and receipt of information also influence how healthcare professionals give information to parents. It has been shown that some people do not want to hear some information, especially information that has a negative element in it,33 38 parents need to be neither completely hopeful nor completely hopeless when receiving information,1 and preparation for receiving medical information should be considered because sometimes expressing this information may harm the mental health of the person 33 39. These findings are consistent with those of this study.…”

Ethical Dilemmas in the Dermatology Outpatient Department in China

“… 32 From the nursing leader’s perspective, this was the preferred option, as it maintains the nurse-patient therapeutic relationship of trust and good communication. 33 Also to be considered are the ethical issues widely referred to in medical ethics as outlined by Benn and Boyd: the individual autonomy of people, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. 32 The principles of autonomy and beneficence are more concerned with individual ethics, whereas justice focuses on social ethics and the formulation of criteria for solving potential conflicts between people.…”

How to Achieve Cross-Cultural and Theoretical Diversities in Clinical Ethics Support Systems

“…In different studies [4][5][6][7], I have shown that the above engagement is not only desirable, but possible. In one study Ewuoso [4], I showed how a particular African ethics may be used to address the ethical impasse created by applying coercion in psychiatric care.…”