Signatures of Subacute Potentially Catastrophic Illness in the ICU: Model Development and Validation*

Abstract

Objective Patients in intensive care units are susceptible to subacute, potentially catastrophic illnesses such as respiratory failure, sepsis, and hemorrhage that present as severe derangements of vital signs. More subtle physiologic signatures may be present before clinical deterioration, when treatment might be more effective. We performed multivariate statistical analyses of bedside physiologic monitoring data to identify such early, subclinical signatures of incipient life-threatening illness. Design We report a study of model development and validation of a retrospective observational cohort using resampling (TRIPOD Type 1b internal validation), and a study of model validation using separate data (Type 2b internal/external validation). Setting University of Virginia Health System (Charlottesville), a tertiary-care, academic medical center. Patients Critically ill patients consecutively admitted between January 2009 and June 2015 to either the neonatal, surgical/trauma/burn, or medical intensive care units with available physiologic monitoring data. Interventions None. Measurements and Main Results We analyzed 146 patient-years of vital sign and electrocardiography waveform time series from the bedside monitors of 9,232 ICU admissions. Calculations from 30-minute windows of the physiologic monitoring data were made every 15 minutes. Clinicians identified 1,206 episodes of respiratory failure leading to urgent, unplanned intubation, sepsis, or hemorrhage leading to multi-unit transfusions from systematic, individual chart reviews. Multivariate models to predict events up to 24 hours prior had internally-validated C-statistics of 0.61 to 0.88. In adults, physiologic signatures of respiratory failure and hemorrhage were distinct from each other but externally consistent across ICUs. Sepsis, on the other hand, demonstrated less distinct and inconsistent signatures. Physiologic signatures of all neonatal illnesses were similar. Conclusions Subacute, potentially catastrophic illnesses in 3 diverse ICU populations have physiologic signatures that are detectable in the hours preceding clinical detection and intervention. Detection of such signatures can draw attention to patients at highest risk, potentially enabling earlier intervention and better outcomes.

Sepsis reconsidered: Identifying novel metrics for behavioral landscape characterization with a high-performance computing implementation of an agent-based model

“…The methodology employed for the development of all these scoring systems all assume that the data sets utilized sufficiently represent the overall set of behaviors possible, which the current study demonstrates is not the case. In fact, given the “bowtie structure” of biological signaling and regulatory networks [39], dynamic physiology-based prediction systems [34, 40, 41] likely have a greater chance of success in refining individual patient trajectories, but at the cost of not providing insight into the mechanistic drivers that would be potential targets for therapeutic control. Future work with simulation-based characterization of sepsis will likely involve mapping between computationally-generated behavioral landscapes and finer-grained temporal clinical phenotype characterization using advanced physiological metrics to guide discovery of mechanistic determinants of individual patient trajectories.…”

Novel pediatric‐automated respiratory score using physiologic data and machine learning in asthma

“…The use of pediatric clinical scoring systems in clinical care and research has exploded in the last decade. Clinical scoring systems appeal to multiple stakeholders because they are quantitative, can be validated and improve patient outcomes . Pediatric asthma is no exception; as the most common chronic disease of childhood, development of clinical scores and guidelines have helped to streamline and improve pediatric asthma care delivery …”

From static to dynamic: a sepsis-specific dynamic model from clinical criteria in polytrauma patients

“…A dynamic decision support system that accurately predicts sepsis could focus limited resources, avoid 'alert fatigue' that may accompany decision support systems, and decrease procedural complications for patients. Indeed, work from multiple groups, key among them Moorman and collaborators, has focused on the clinical prognostic value of dynamic assessment of physiologic waveforms (e.g., heart rate variability) in the setting of pediatric sepsis (24,25).…”