NIDA-Drug Addiction Treatment Outcome Study (DATOS) Relapse as a Function of Spirituality/Religiosity

Abstract

BackgroundThe connection between religion/spirituality and deviance, like substance abuse, was first made by Durkheim who defined socially expected behaviors as norms. He explained that deviance is due in large part to their absence (called anomie), and concluded that spirituality lowers deviance by preserving norms and social bonds. Impairments in brain reward circuitry, as observed in Reward Deficiency Syndrome (RDS), may also result in deviance and as such we wondered if stronger belief in spirituality practice and religious belief could lower relapse from drugs of abuse.MethodsThe NIDA Drug Addiction Treatment Outcome Study data set was used to examine post hoc relapse rates among 2,947 clients who were interviewed at 12 months after intake broken down by five spirituality measures.ResultsOur main findings strongly indicate, that those with low spirituality have higher relapse rates and those with high spirituality have higher remission rates with crack use being the sole exception. We found significant differences in terms of cocaine, heroin, alcohol, and marijuana relapse as a function of strength of religious beliefs (x2 = 15.18, p = 0.028; logistic regression = 10.65, p = 0.006); frequency of attending religious services (x2 = 40.78, p < 0.0005; logistic regression = 30.45, p < 0.0005); frequency of reading religious books (x2 = 27.190, p < 0.0005; logistic regression = 17.31, p < 0.0005); frequency of watching religious programs (x2 = 19.02, p = 0.002; logistic regression = ns); and frequency of meditation/prayer (x2 = 11.33, p = 0.045; logistic regression = 9.650, p = 0.002). Across the five measures of spirituality, the spiritual participants reported between 7% and 21% less alcohol, cocaine, heroin, and marijuana use than the non-spiritual subjects. However, the crack users who reported that religion was not important reported significantly less crack use than the spiritual participants. The strongest association between remission and spirituality involves attending religious services weekly, the one marker of the five that involves the highest social interaction/social bonding consistent with Durkheim’s social bond theory.ConclusionsStronger spiritual/religious beliefs and practices are directly associated with remission from abused drugs except crack. Much like the value of having a sponsor, for clients who abuse drugs, regular spiritual practice, particularly weekly attendance at the religious services of their choice is associated with significantly higher remission. These results demonstrate the clinically significant role of spirituality and the social bonds it creates in drug treatment programs.

Ibogaine and addiction in the animal model, a systematic review and meta-analysis

“…Despite treatment, 5-year relapse rates are as high as 70% for alcohol dependence, 78% for cocaine dependence and 97% for opioid dependence. 4 , 5 , 6 Moreover, for opioid dependence, pharmacological treatment mainly consists of harm reduction strategies, using opioid substitution with opioid agonists 7 , 8 and for cocaine dependence no effective pharmacological treatment is available at all. 9…”

An empirical study on the construct of “God” in the Twelve Step process

“…We consider the issue of spirituality here, as it provides the overarching context in which the construct of "God" is to be understood. The role of spirituality in 12 Step membership has been found to be associated with a positive outcome of SUD treatment (4,5,24), and as a mediator of the positive outcome associated with 12 Step recovery (25)(26)(27). Additionally, as noted above, the self-reported experience of "spiritual awakening," referred to in the last (12 th ) Step, has been found to be associated with both decreased craving among established 12 Step members (28) and leading to an increased likelihood of abstinent outcome following treatment (7,29,30).…”

Contextual Perspectives on Heroin Addiction and Recovery: Classic and Contemporary Theories

“…While our article covered heroin use, dependence, prevalence, abstinence, prevention, recovery, and relapse as physical and emotional problem; and more biological aspects were not reviewed, such as research by Blum, et al [97] who found that carriers of the DRD2 A1 allele bind together like "birds of a feather flock together" showing that there is even biological evidence for the importance of friendship networks. In addition, although we focused on employment issues, educational level [98] as well as religiosity [99] also have important implications for understanding this area. Also, many of the articles refer to psychoactive substances and are not specific to heroin.…”