Cortical Thickness Maturation and Duration of Music Training: Health-Promoting Activities Shape Brain Development

Abstract

Objective To assess the extent to which playing a musical instrument is associated with cortical thickness development among healthy youths. Method Participants were part of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) Study of Normal Brain Development. This study followed a longitudinal design such that participants underwent MRI scanning and behavioral testing on up to three separate visits, occurring at 2-year intervals. MRI, IQ, and music training data were available for 232 youths (334 scans), ranging from 6–18 years of age. Cortical thickness was regressed against the number of years each youth had played a musical instrument. Next, thickness was regressed against an “Age × Years of Playing” interaction term. Age, gender, total brain volume, and scanner were controlled for in analyses. Participant ID was entered as a random effect to account for within-person dependence. False discovery rate correction was applied (p ≤ 0.05). Results There was no association between thickness and years playing a musical instrument. The “Age × Years of Playing” interaction was associated with thickness in motor, premotor, and supplementary motor cortices, as well as prefrontal and parietal cortices. Follow-up analysis revealed that musical training was associated with an increased rate of thickness maturation. Results were largely unchanged when IQ and handedness were included as covariates. Conclusion Playing a musical instrument was associated with more rapid cortical thickness maturation within areas implicated in motor planning and coordination, visuospatial ability, and emotion and impulse regulation. However, given the quasi-experimental nature of this study, we cannot rule out the influence of confounding variables.

Does physical activity protect against drug abuse vulnerability?

“…Two recent studies with pre-adolescent school age children show a modest impact of aerobic exercise on executive functioning, especially for more intense exercise (Davis et al, 2011;Kamijo et al, 2011). However, while exercise may have only a modest direct benefit on executive functioning, the impact may be enhanced by additional interventions such as mindfulness training (Diamond and Lee, 2011), parental modeling (Pentz and Riggs, 2013) or musical training (Hudziak et al, 2014). Most recently, an afterschool exercise program with 7 to 9 year old children was shown to enhance executive control in a well-designed trial with 221 participants (Hillman et al, 2014).…”

Development of cortical shape in the human brain from 6 to 24months of age via a novel measure of shape complexity

“…Many quantitative brain morphometric measurements, such as regional volumes (Holland et al, 2014; Koran et al, 2014; Lange et al, 2015; Marcus Jenkins et al, 2013; Sowell et al, 2002), cortical thickness, and surface area (Hudziak et al, 2014; Sowell et al, 2004; Storsve et al, 2014; Zielinski et al, 2014) have been used to analyze for brain development, clinical differences, and diagnostic guidelines. These measurements allow for analyses of the global or local developmental trajectory over age, differential anatomical changes, and the relationship between anatomical changes and brain functions or environment factors.…”

Evaluating the evidence in evidence-based policy and practice: Examples from systematic reviews of literature

“…This is promising but one of the studies (Olson 2010;Schlaug et al 2005) found that there was no difference between music and control children in terms of academic performance. Hudziak et al's (2014) study showed a positive correlation between music training and visuo-spatial and motor coordination as evidenced by the thickening of the brain cortex. However, the correlational design of the study (with no comparators) makes it difficult to say how much of the change was just due to musical training.…”