“…Since the first report of N. ceranae infection in A. mellifera, there has been some controversy about the consequences of such infection. However, in recent years most studies have confirmed that N. ceranae has a pathogenic effect in this host, expressed at least in a shortening of the workers' lifespan in controlled (cage) experiment (e.g., Mayack and Naug, 2009;Alaux et al, 2010;Martín-Hern andez et al, 2011;Dussaubat et al, 2012;Goblirsch et al, 2013;Schwarz and Evans, 2013;Aufauvre et al, 2014;Basualdo et al, 2014;Roberts and Hughes, 2014;2015;Williams et al, 2014;Doublet et al, 2015aHuang et al, 2015; only few papers failing to report this effect (Milbrath et al, 2013;Retschnig et al, 2014;Garrido et al, 2016).…”