Driving evaluation methods for able-bodied persons and individuals with lower extremity disabilities: a review of assessment modalities

Abstract

Assessing the driving abilities of individuals with disabilities is often a very challenging task because each medical condition is accompanied by physical impairments and because relative individual functional performance may vary depending on personal characteristics.We identified existing driving evaluation modalities for able-bodied and lower extremity-impaired subjects (spinal cord injury patients and amputees) and evaluated the potential relationships between driving performance and the motor component of driving.An extensive scoping review of the literature was conducted to identify driving assessment tools that are currently used for able-bodied individuals and for those with spinal cord injury or lower extremity amputation. The literature search focused on the assessment of the motor component of driving. References were electronically obtained via Medline from the PubMed, Ovid, Web of Science and Google Scholar databases.This article compares the current assessments of driving performance for those with lower extremity impairments with the assessments used for able-bodied persons. Very few articles were found concerning “Lower Extremity Disabilities,” thus confirming the need for further studies that can provide evidence and guidance for such assessments in the future. Little is known about the motor component of driving and its association with the other driving domains, such as vision and cognition. The available research demonstrates the need for a more evidenced-based understanding of how to best evaluate persons with lower extremity impairment.

A novel low-cost solution for driving assessment in individuals with and without disabilities

“…6-9 Reaction time is a derivative of several sensorimotor capabilities–mainly an individual's cognitive, neuromuscular, and visual capacity. Although the impact of these capabilities themselves on driving performance is not clearly understood, 10 tests that impart a load on a driver's cognitive, motor, and-or visual domains can alter brake reaction time. Therefore, they are useful in assessing one's driving ability.…”

“…For these reasons, reaction time assessments in studies concerning driving ability are generally measured using commercial driving simulators. 10 …”

An Evaluation Method of Safe Driving for Senior Adults Using ECG Signals

“…This should model and quantify the relationship between the driver’s condition and the vehicle’s motion. Assessing the driving abilities of the elderly with disabilities is often a very challenging task because each medical condition is accompanied by physical impairments, and relative individual functional performance may vary depending on personal characteristics [15].…”

Preditores do tempo de frenagem no simulador virtual de direção para motoristas com paraplegia

“…As pessoas com deficiência física enfrentam grandes desafios para a direção veicular, pois precisam escolher entre as várias opções de acessibilidade para operar um veículo automotor. São diversas as doenças que cursam com sequelas motoras que limitam a habilidade para dirigir um veículo automotor regular (Greve et al, 2015). Frear um veículo automotor é uma tarefa motora que depende da capacidade do condutor processar as informações ambientais, tomar a decisão e acionar o freio para evitar uma colisão, com sua medida feita em segundos (Alonso et al, 2016;Schmidt e Wrisberg, 2001).…”

“…Porém, poucas são as pesquisas sobre as adaptações e treinamentos necessários, havendo falta de informações sobre quais as habilidades necessárias para uma pessoa com deficiência física dirigir um veículo automotor de forma segura(Greve et al 2015). das funções dos segmentos corpóreos envolvidos na segurança de direção veicular.Por exemplo, amputação de membros e sequelas neurológicas.Segurança é o principal ponto do treinamento de novos condutores, pois os acidentes de trânsito causam 3.400 mortes/dia em todo o mundo(WHO, 2015).…”