Laparoendoscopic pfannenstiel nephrectomy using conventional laparoscopic instruments - preliminary experience

Abstract

Purpose: To confirm the feasibility of the laparoendoscopic Pfannenstiel nephrectomy using conventional laparoscopic instruments. Materials and Methods: Since March 2009, laparoscopic nephrectomy through a Pfannenstiel incision has been performed in selected patients in our service. The Veress needle was placed through the umbilicus which allowed carbon dioxide inflow. One 5 mm (or 10 mm) trocar was placed at the umbilicus for the laparoscope, to guide the placement of three trocars over the Pfannenstiel incision. Additional trocars were placed as follows: a 10 mm in the midline, a 10 mm ipsilateral to the kidney to be removed (2 cm away from the middle one), and a 5 mm contralateral to the kidney to be removed (2 cm away from the middle one). The entire procedure was performed using conventional laparoscopic instruments. At the end of the surgery, trocars were removed and all three incisions were united into a single Pfannenstiel incision for specimen retrieval. Results: Five nephrectomies were performed following this technique: one atrophic kidney, one kidney donation, two renal cancers and one bilateral renal atrophy. Median operative time was 100 minutes and median intraoperative blood loss was 100 cc. No intraoperative complications occurred and no patients required blood transfusion. Median length of hospital stay was 1 day (range 1 to 2 days). Conclusions: The use of the Pfannenstiel incision for laparoscopic nephrectomy seems to be feasible even when using conventional laparoscopic instruments, and can be considered a potential alternative for traditional laparoscopic nephrectomy.

Laparoscopic nephrectomy – Pfannenstiel or expanded port site specimen extraction: a systematic review and meta-analysis

“…LN results in less post-operative pain, improved cosmesis, a shorter hospital stay and an earlier return to daily activities when compared with open nephrectomy. These benefits are achieved without compromising oncological outcomes [ 4 ]. Current options for intact specimen extraction include an expanded port site (EPS), connecting port site incisions, utilising old abdominal scars or by creating new incisions (such as a paramedian, Pfannenstiel (PFN) or modified iliac fossa) [ 2 ].…”