Accounting conservatism in Portugal: similarities and differences facing Germany and the United Kingdom

Abstract

This paper examines the existence of conservative practices in the Portuguese accounting system, and whether these conservative practices affect the comparability of financial information provided by companies. We particularly examine whether the book value figure can be understated due to conservative practices to protect creditors' interests (balance sheet conservatism) and whether accountants delay the recognition in earnings of good news, while they recognize immediately bad news (earnings conservatism). Using a Basu (1997) type reverse regression and a simple adaptation of the Ohlson (1995) valuation model, the paper gives evidence concerning the existence of both definitions of conservatism in Portuguese accounting practices. A sample of non-financial Portuguese, German and British companies was used. Our results also show the larger earnings conservatism of British firms relative to Portugal and Germany, and surprisingly, that Portugal is more BS (larger understatement of shareholders' equity) conservative than the United Kingdom. The results have implications for accounting standard setting and they can be useful for both the European Commission and the IASB since they provide some insight into the properties of accounting figures in Portugal.

Institutional Change of Accounting Systems: The Adoption of a Regime of Adapted International Financial Reporting Standards

“…Financial institutions are the main providers of capital for SMEs. Capital markets are not especially important in the Portuguese financial system (Ferreira, García Lara, & Gonçalves, 2007): in September 2010, only 52 companies were listed on the Portuguese Stock Exchange (Euronext, 2010). Because there is a small stock market, the low level of concern in Portugal for investors' needs is unsurprising.…”

“…As a consequence, there is greater concern in Portugal with issues of tax determination and creditor protection. This leads to more prudent and conservative accounting (Ferreira, 1998;Ferreira et al, 2007).…”

The evolution of financial accounting in Portugal since the 1960s: A new institutional economics perspective

“…The POC / 77 was a means of regulating the provision of accounting information that prior to 1977 did not have a uniform approach to income determination. While its benefits were to accrue in the context of financial change, by a wide range of users, 22 it was a measurement system concerned with the uniform measurement of income, primarily to facilitate the operation of a national taxation system for companies (Carqueja, 1997; Ferreira, 1998; Ferreira et al, 2007). According to Noel Monteiro (1980: 184), accounting in Portugal had been organised according to tax criteria, promoting a “tax mentality” among accountants, who even started to “consider accounting rules, including those that were no more than tax rules”.…”

Gestão de resultados: evidência europeia das empresas cotadas VERSUS não cotadas

“…Estamos perante práticas de gestão de resultados quando os gestores utilizam o seu juízo de valor por forma a alterar os relatórios financeiros com o intuito de transparecerem para os stakeholders um desempenho económico da empresa diferente do real, quando influenciam os resultados contratuais que se encontram dependentes de números contabilísticos divulgados ou com vista à obtenção de um determinado ganho privado (Schipper, 1989;Healy e Wahlen, 1999). Assim, a gestão de resultados pode conduzir a uma menor qualidade dos resultados e, por conseguinte, a uma diminuição da confiança dos stakeholders (Dechow e Schrand, 2004;Dechow, Ge, Larson e Sloan, 2011;Ferreira, García Lara e Gonçalves, 2007).…”