Malaria vectors can reach very high densities in villages near irrigated rice fields in Africa, leading to the expectation that malaria should be especially prevalent there. Surprisingly, this is not always the case. In Niono, Mali, villages from nonirrigated areas have higher malaria prevalence than those within the irrigated regions, which suffer from higher mosquito numbers. One hypothesis explaining this observation is that mosquitoes from irrigated fields with high densities are inefficient vectors. This could occur if higher larval densities lead to smaller mosquitoes that suffer elevated mortality. Three predictions of the hypothesis were studied. First, the effect of larval density on larval body size was measured for both Anopheles gambiae Giles and Anopheles funestus Giles. Second, the relationship between larval and adult body size was tested. Third, evidence of an effect of adult size on survivorship in both irrigated and nonirrigated villages during the wet and dry seasons was sought. There was a modest positive relationship between densities of immatures and larval size, and a strong relationship between larval and adult size. Furthermore, adult survivorship was higher in nonirrigated areas. However, there was no effect of size on survivorship between comparable samples from both the irrigated and nonirrigated zones. Although density may have a causal relationship with reduced transmission in the irrigated areas of Niono, it is unlikely to be because higher density leads to smaller body size and lower survivorship.
KeywordsAnopheles; irrigation; size; density; survivorship Irrigation in Sub-Saharan Africa can be a mixed blessing. It contributes to greater food production and income; however, it may increase the incidence of diseases such as schistosomiasis and malaria (Service 1989 a,b;Dzodzomenyo et al. 1999;van der Hoek 2004 ). It is surprising, then, that several investigators have reported malaria transmission to be the same, or even less, in irrigated areas with high vector densities than in nearby nonirrigated areas with lower numbers of mosquitoes ( Ijumba and Lindsay 2001, Diuk-Wasser et al. 2005a ). For example, Dolo et al. (2004) Sissoko et al. 2004 ). Reasons for this departure from expectation may include 1) the nuisance of so many mosquitoes might compel more people to use bednets; 2) the greater prosperity of irrigated areas might permit access to better health care, protection, or both; or, 3) the mosquitoes that emerge from the high-density irrigated areas during the rainy season might be less efficient at transmitting malaria, e.g., if they do not survive as well ( Diuk-Wasser et al. 2005a ).This study tests the hypothesis that body size is the cause of reduced vector survivorship at high density, leading to lower malaria transmission measured by vectorial capacity ( Diuk-Wasser et al. 2005a ) and prevalence ( Sissoko et al. 2004 ) in the irrigated areas of Niono. Several aspects of this hypothesis are supported by previous work; in the irrigated zone, high density during ...