Carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) emissions are central to the climate crisis and their consequences indiscriminately affect natural and anthropogenic ecosystems. Among ecological interactions, those between plants and insects are among the most impacted by the elevation in CO 2 concentration (eCO 2 ). We selected a plant and an herbivore species of worldwide relevance and tested the hypothesis that eCO 2 affects leaf quality and defences of sunflower, Helianthus annuus L. (Asteraceae), and negatively impacts the larval preference and performance of the important pest Helicoverpa armigera H€ ubner (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Plants and insects developed inside open-top chambers under ambient CO 2 (ca. 400 ppm) and eCO 2 (ca. 800 ppm). Sunflowers under eCO 2 grew more (e.g., increased height and had more leaves) but were of lower nutritional quality at an early developmental stage (e.g., lower nitrogen content, greater leaf thickness, and higher flavonoids content). Despite showing no preference for either treatment, H. armigera larvae performed better when fed with leaves from eCO 2 plants. We argue this was observed because larvae under eCO 2 sustained a greater leaf consumption, even when sunflower leaf quality became similar between treatments (by the 11th week after germination). Besides, they overcompensated a more deficient diet during early developmental stages and presented a higher growth rate; ca. 2.59 more individuals reached the pupal stage, and 49 more individuals became adults. The improvement in H. armigera larval performance under eCO 2 indicates a worrisome scenario in which a species that already exerts a significant impact on ecosystems would increase its consumption, develop faster, and support a larger population size.