There has recently
been greater appreciation for the impact that n →
π* interactions have on the conformational
preferences of molecules in the gas phase, solution, and crystalline
form. Earlier studies, both experimental and computational, have demonstrated
that suitably placed substituents can affect the extent of these interactions.
A thorough understanding of how substituents affect these interactions
is necessary for these forces to be potentially utilized as a means
of crystal engineering. We synthesized a series of 2-(dimethylamino)biphenyl-2′-carboxaldehydes
substituted at the position para to the aldehyde
group with substituents ranging in electronic properties from strong
electron-withdrawing to strong electron-donating and determined their
structures via X-ray crystallography. In all cases, evidence suggests
that the conformations adopted in the crystals retained n → π* interactions. However, contrary to computational
studies conducted in vacuo, the geometries varied
not according to the substituents’ electronic properties (as
described by Hammett σp values) as expected but instead
according to their steric properties (using Sotomatsu and Fujita’s
steric parameters; J. Org. Chem.1989544443; Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn.1992652343). Calculations on representative molecular
clusters demonstrate that the geometries adopted in the crystal form
are such that they minimize destabilizing intermolecular steric interactions,
while maximizing stabilizing intermolecular dispersive and electrostatic
forces. This comes at fairly low energetic cost to the molecules relative
to their optimized theoretical in vacuo geometries
(generally less than 0.5 kcal/mol) even though it stresses, but does
not overwhelm, the intramolecular n → π*
interactions.