Elastic electron-proton scattering (e−p) and the spectroscopy of hydrogen atoms are the two traditional methods used to determine the proton charge radius (r p). About a decade ago, a new method using muonic hydrogen (µH) atoms 1 found a significant discrepancy with the compilation of all previous results 2 , creating the "proton radius puzzle". Despite intensive worldwide experimental and theoretical efforts, the "puzzle" remains unresolved. In fact, a new discrepancy was reported between the two most recent spectroscopic measurements on ordinary hydrogen 3, 4. Here, we report on the PRad experiment, the first high-precision e − p experiment since the emergence of the "puzzle". For the first time, a magnetic-spectrometerfree method was employed along with a windowless hydrogen gas target, which overcame several limitations of previous e − p experiments and reached unprecedented small angles.
The PRad experiment has credibly demonstrated the advantages of the calorimetric method in e − p scattering experiments to measure the proton root-mean-square (RMS) charge radius with high accuracy. The PRad result, within its experimental uncertainties, is in agreement with the small radius measured in muonic hydrogen spectroscopy experiments and it was a critical input in the recent revision of the CODATA recommendation for the proton charge radius. Consequently, the PRad result is in direct conflict with all modern electron scattering experiments. Most importantly, it is 5.8% smaller than the value from the most precise electron scattering experiment to date, and this difference is about three standard deviations given the precision of the PRad experiment. As the first experiment of its kind, PRad did not reach the highest precision allowed by the calorimetric technique. Here we propose a new (and) upgraded experiment -PRad-II, which will reduce the overall experimental uncertainties by a factor of 3.8 compared to PRad and address this as yet unsettled controversy in subatomic physics. In addition, PRad-II will be the first lepton scattering experiment to reach the Q 2 range of 10 −5 GeV 2 allowing a more accurate and robust extraction of the proton charge radius. The muonic hydrogen result with its unprecedented precision ( 0.05%) determines the CODATA value of the proton charge radius, hence, it is critical to evaluate possible systematic uncertainties of those experiments, such as the laser frequency calibration that was raised in recent review articles. The PRad-II experiment with its projected total uncertainty of 0.43% could demonstrate whether there is any systematic difference between e − p scattering and muonic hydrogen results. PRad-II will establish a new precision frontier in electron scattering and open doors for future physics opportunities. * Contact person † Spokesperson
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.