We conducted a retrospective parallel cohort study comparing surgical and medical treatment for epilepsy. The surgical group contained all 201 patients treated with resective surgery for epilepsy in Norway since the first operation in 1949 until January 1988. The 185 patients in the control group, medically treated only, were closely matched for year of treatment, age at treatment, sex, seizure type, and neurologic deficit before treatment. Between 75 and 95% of the survivors (median 17 years after treatment) completed two questionnaires on their social situation. Although surgical treatment improved the seizure situation (about one-fourth had some neurologic deficit), a considerably smaller long-range influence on different social aspects was observed. There were no significant differences between the two groups in educational status, social pensions, social status, marital status, fertility, dependency in residential situation, the need for aid in daily activities of living (ADL), or the need for being looked after, when we controlled for pretreatment status. In all, 25.3% of the surgically treated patients and 8.5% of the controls were not receiving anti-epileptic drugs (AEDs) at the time of investigation (Mann-Whitney U test, two-tailed p = 0.0011). A considerably higher proportion of the surgically treated (53.2%) than control patients (24.2%) claimed that the treatment had improved their "working ability" (Mann-Whitney U test, two-tailed p less than 0.0001), but this resulted in significant improvements in the actual working situation only for those in regular education or work before treatment (chi 2 = 6.514, p = 0.038).
We conducted a longitudinal self-controlled study of 131 patients aged 4-60 treated with resective surgery for medically uncontrolled partial epilepsy from 1949 to 1988. Using multivariate logistic regression, we showed that pre- and perioperative variables can be used to predict "success" or "failure" of surgical resective treatment in approximately 79% of cases. If the predicted probability is > 0.75 or < 0.25, the model predicts a correct result in 87% of cases. Eight predictive factors emerged with a backward multivariate logistic regression model with the likelihood-ratio (LR) test to exclude variables from the equation: (a) the influence of the surgical team and surgical procedure, (b) the presence of paresis preoperatively, (c) duration of disease, (d) age at treatment, (e) positive neuroradiologic findings in preoperative investigations, (f) preoperative complex partial seizures (CPS), (g) nonepileptic EEG abnormalities, and (h) generalized spike activity in EEG preoperatively. Sex, age at first seizure, area of resection, presence of simple or generalized seizures preoperatively, preoperative seizure frequency, tissue pathology, use of computed tomography/nuclear magnetic resonance (CT/NMR) in preoperative investigations, degree of preoperative neurologic deficit, perioperative electrocorticographic results, and bilateral EEG spikes did not have predictive value in the model.
We conducted a retrospective parallel longitudinal cohort study comparing surgical and medical treatment for epilepsy. The surgical group contained 201 patients treated with resective surgery for epilepsy in Norway since the first operation in 1949 until January 1988. The 185 control group patients treated medically only were closely matched for year of treatment, age at treatment, sex, seizure type, and neurologic deficit before treatment. There was no significant difference in survival between the two groups. The total monthly seizure frequency in the first and second year after operation and last year of registration (median 9 years) was significantly lower in the surgical group than in the control group (Mann-Whitney U test, two-tailed p less than 0.0001). The patterns were similar, with significant differences for subgroups with similar pretreatment status, such as seizure frequency, age, etiology and EEG-focality. Twenty-three and four-tenths percent (n = 40) of the surgically treated, and 2.9% of the controls had contracted neurologic deficits within 2 years after treatment. The difference was significant (chi square = 32.89, p less than 0.0001). Psychosis or permanent psychotic symptoms were reported in 6.7% (n = 11) of the surgically treated patients, and we suspect a higher proportion of psychotic development in the surgical group than in the control group. We conclude that surgical treatment for partial epilepsy is more successful than medical treatment in producing seizure reduction, provided the indications for operation exist. Surgical treatment produces more neurologic deficits than medical treatment (and possibly more psychiatric morbidity), and this factor must be weighed against the reduction in seizure frequency. The two treatments are equal for longterm survival.
We conducted a retrospective longitudinal self-controlled study of 124 adult patients treated with resective surgery for medically uncontrolled partial epilepsy from 1949 to 1988. Approximately 65% of the patients experienced > 95% reduction in seizure frequency, and 75% had worthwhile improvement of at least 75% seizure reduction. Significant reductions were noted in all major seizure types treatable with resective surgery; complex partial (CPS), simple partial (SPS), and secondarily generalized tonic-clonic seizures (GTC) (all p < 0.05). Tissue pathology and region of resection did not provide significant information with respect to seizure outcome. EEG in the first postoperative year was an important predictor of long-term seizure outcome (p = 0.03). One third of the temporal lobe resected patients had neurologic deficits as a consequence of the resection as compared with 14% of patients with frontal resections (p = 0.03). One third of the deficits among the temporal lobe resected patients were considerable, with possible social implications. Half of the patients with preoperative focal spike activity had a normal EEG postoperatively. One fifth of patients maintained their preoperative epileptic focus after the operation, and about one fifth displayed new foci. Approximately one fourth of the patients were free of medication for a median of 16 years postoperatively, and 60% of patients who were seizure-free were still receiving medication. There was no operative mortality, but the late mortality, as expected, was higher than that of the general population. Two male patients (1.6%) committed suicide.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.