The human cytidine deaminase APOBEC3G edits both nascent human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and murine leukemia virus (MLV) reverse transcripts, resulting in loss of infectivity. The HIV Vif protein is able to protect both viruses from this innate restriction to infection. Here, we demonstrate that a number of other APOBEC family members from both humans and rodents can mediate anti-HIV effects, through cytidine deamination. Three of these, rat APOBEC1, mouse APOBEC3, and human APOBEC3B, are able to inhibit HIV infectivity even in the presence of Vif. Like APOBEC3G, human APOBEC3F preferentially restricts vif-deficient virus. Indeed, the mutation spectra and expression profile found for APOBEC3F indicate that this enzyme, together with APOBEC3G, accounts for the G to A hypermutation of proviruses described in HIV-infected individuals. Surprisingly, although MLV infectivity is acutely reduced by APOBEC3G, no other family member tested here had this effect. It is especially interesting that although both rodent APOBECs markedly diminish wild-type HIV infectivity, MLV is resistant to these proteins. This implies that MLV may have evolved to avoid deamination by mouse APOBEC3. Overall, our findings show that although APOBEC family members are highly related, they exhibit significantly distinct antiviral characteristics that may provide new insights into host-pathogen interactions.

The antiretroviral activity of the cellular enzyme APOBEC3G has been attributed to the excessive deamination of cytidine (C) to uridine (U) in minus strand reverse transcripts, a process resulting in guanosine (G) to adenosine (A) hypermutation of plus strand DNAs. The HIV-1 Vif protein counteracts APOBEC3G by inducing proteasomal degradation and exclusion from virions through recruitment of a cullin5 ECS E3 ubiquitin ligase complex. APOBEC3G belongs to the APOBEC protein family, members of which possess consensus (H/C)-(A/V)-E-(X)24-30-P-C-(X)2-C cytidine deaminase motifs. Earlier analyses of APOBEC-1 have defined specific residues that are important for zinc coordination, proton transfer, and, therefore, catalysis within this motif. Because APOBEC3G contains two such motifs, we used site-directed mutagenesis of conserved residues to assess each region's contribution to anti-HIV-1 activity. Surprisingly, whereas either the N- or C-terminal domain could confer antiviral function in tissue culture-based infectivity assays, only an intact C-terminal motif was essential for DNA mutator activity. These findings reveal the nonequivalency of APOBEC3G's N- and C-terminal domains and imply that APOBEC3G-mediated DNA editing may not always be necessary for antiviral activity. Accordingly, we propose that APOBEC3G can achieve an anti-HIV-1 effect through an undescribed mechanism that is distinct from cytidine deamination.

APOBEC3F (apolipoprotein B mRNA-editing enzyme catalytic polypeptide 1-like protein 3F) is a cytidine deaminase that, like APOBEC3G, is able to restrict the replication of HIV-1/delta vif. Initial studies revealed high numbers of mutations in the cDNA of viruses produced in the presence of these proteins, suggesting that cytidine deamination underpinned the inhibition of infection. However, we have recently shown that catalytically inactive APOBEC3G proteins, derived through mutation of the C-terminal cytidine deaminase motif, still exert a substantial antiviral effect. Here, we have generated a panel of APOBEC3F mutant proteins and show that the C-terminal cytidine deaminase motif is essential for catalytic activity and that catalytic activity is not necessary for the antiviral effect of APOBEC3F. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the antiviral activities of wild-type and catalytically inactive APOBEC3F and APOBEC3G proteins correspond well with reductions in the accumulation of viral reverse transcription products. Additional comparisons between APOBEC3F and APOBEC3G suggest that the loss of deaminase activity is more detrimental to APOBEC3G function than to APOBEC3F function, as reflected by perturbations to the suppression of reverse transcript accumulation as well as antiviral activity. Taken together, these data suggest that both APOBEC3F and APOBEC3G are able to function as antiviral factors in the absence of cytidine deamination, that this editing-independent activity is an important aspect of APOBEC protein-mediated antiviral phenotypes, but that APOBEC3F may be a better model in which to study it.