Purpose:To determine the performance of positron emission mammography (PEM), as compared with magnetic resonance (MR) imaging, including the effect on surgical management, in ipsilateral breasts with cancer.
Materials and Methods:Four hundred seventy-two women with newly diagnosed breast cancer who were offered breast-conserving surgery consented from September 2006 to November 2008 to participate in a multicenter institutional review board-approved, HIPAA-compliant protocol. Participants underwent contrast material-enhanced MR imaging and fl uorine 18 fl uorodeoxyglucose PEM in randomized order; resultant images were interpreted independently. Added biopsies and changes in surgical procedure for the ipsilateral breast were correlated with histopathologic fi ndings. Performance characteristics were compared by using the McNemar test and generalized estimating equations.
Results:Three hundred eighty-eight women (median age, 58 years; age range, 26-93 years; median estimated tumor size, 1.5 cm) completed the study. Additional cancers were found in 82 (21%) (41%) were depicted by PEM ( P = .043). Fifty-six (14%) of the 388 women required mastectomy: 40 (71%) of these women were identifi ed with MR imaging, and 20 (36%) were identifi ed with PEM ( P , .001). Eleven (2.8%) women underwent unnecessary mastectomy, which was prompted by only MR fi ndings in fi ve women, by only PEM fi ndings in one, and by PEM and MR fi ndings in fi ve. Thirty-three (8.5%) women required wider excision: 24 (73%) of these women were identifi ed with MR imaging, and 22 (67%) were identifi ed with PEM.
Conclusion:PEM and MR imaging had comparable breast-level sensitivity, although MR imaging had greater lesion-level sensitivity and more accurately depicted the need for mastectomy. PEM had greater specifi city at the breast and lesion levels. Eighty-nine (23%) participants required more extensive surgery: 61 (69%) of these women were identifi ed with MR imaging, and 41 (46%) were identifi ed with PEM ( P = .003). Fourteen (3.6%) women had tumors seen only at PEM.
PEM was more sensitive than either WBPET or PET/CT in showing index and additional ipsilateral breast tumors and remained highly sensitive for tumors smaller than 1 cm.
Contralateral cancer was found in 15 of 367 women (4.1%), with MRI showing 14 (93%). Eleven contralateral cancers (73%) were visible on PEM, but only three (20%) were recognized prospectively as suspicious. Lesions that are visible on PEM should be viewed as suspicious unless known to be benign by prior breast imaging or biopsy.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.