Hydrogen atoms cannot hide from x-rays anymore but can instead be detected very reliably in routine measurements.
High-resolution low-temperature synchrotron X-ray diffraction data of the salt L-phenylalaninium hydrogen maleate are used to test the new automated iterative Hirshfeld atom refinement (HAR) procedure for the modelling of strong hydrogen bonds. The HAR models used present the first examples of Z' > 1 treatments in the framework of wavefunction-based refinement methods. L-Phenylalaninium hydrogen maleate exhibits several hydrogen bonds in its crystal structure, of which the shortest and the most challenging to model is the O-H...O intramolecular hydrogen bond present in the hydrogen maleate anion (O...O distance is about 2.41 Å). In particular, the reconstruction of the electron density in the hydrogen maleate moiety and the determination of hydrogen-atom properties [positions, bond distances and anisotropic displacement parameters (ADPs)] are the focus of the study. For comparison to the HAR results, different spherical (independent atom model, IAM) and aspherical (free multipole model, MM; transferable aspherical atom model, TAAM) X-ray refinement techniques as well as results from a low-temperature neutron-diffraction experiment are employed. Hydrogen-atom ADPs are furthermore compared to those derived from a TLS/rigid-body (SHADE) treatment of the X-ray structures. The reference neutron-diffraction experiment reveals a truly symmetric hydrogen bond in the hydrogen maleate anion. Only with HAR is it possible to freely refine hydrogen-atom positions and ADPs from the X-ray data, which leads to the best electron-density model and the closest agreement with the structural parameters derived from the neutron-diffraction experiment, e.g. the symmetric hydrogen position can be reproduced. The multipole-based refinement techniques (MM and TAAM) yield slightly asymmetric positions, whereas the IAM yields a significantly asymmetric position.
In this work, the quality of the electron density in crystals reconstructed by the multipolar model (MM) and by X-ray wavefunction refinement (XWR) is tested on a set of high-resolution X-ray diffraction data sets of four amino acids and six tripeptides. It results in the first thorough validation of XWR. Agreement statistics, figures of merit, residual- and deformation-density maps, as well as atomic displacement parameters are used to measure the quality of the reconstruction relative to the measured structure factors. Topological analysis of the reconstructed density is carried out to obtain atomic and bond-topological properties, which are subsequently compared to the values derived from benchmarking periodic DFT geometry optimizations. XWR is simultaneously in better agreement than the MM with both benchmarking theory and the measured diffraction pattern. In particular, the obvious problems with the description of polar bonds in the MM are significantly reduced by using XWR. Similarly, modeling of electron density in the vicinity of hydrogen atoms with XWR is visibly improved.
Hirshfeld atom refinement is one of the most successful methods for the accurate determination of structural parameters for hydrogen atoms from X-ray diffraction data. This work introduces a generalization of the method [generalized atom refinement (GAR)], consisting of the application of various methods of partitioning electron density into atomic contributions. These were tested on three organic structures using the following partitions: Hirshfeld, iterative Hirshfeld, iterative stockholder, minimal basis iterative stockholder and Becke. The effects of partition choice were also compared with those caused by other factors such as quantum chemical methodology, basis set, representation of the crystal field and a combination of these factors. The differences between the partitions were small in terms of R factor (e.g. much smaller than for refinements with different quantum chemistry methods, i.e. Hartree–Fock and coupled cluster) and therefore no single partition was clearly the best in terms of experimental data reconstruction. In the case of structural parameters the differences between the partitions are comparable to those related to the choice of other factors. We have observed the systematic effects of the partition choice on bond lengths and ADP values of polar hydrogen atoms. The bond lengths were also systematically influenced by the choice of electron density calculation methodology. This suggests that GAR-derived structural parameters could be systematically improved by selecting an optimal combination of the partition and quantum chemistry method. The results of the refinements were compared with those of neutron diffraction experiments. This allowed a selection of the most promising partition methods for further optimization of GAR settings, namely the Hirshfeld, iterative stockholder and minimal basis iterative stockholder.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.