Abstract. The use of ground-based precipitation measurements in radar precipitation
estimation is well known in radar hydrology. However, the approach of using
gauged precipitation and near-surface air temperature observations to improve
radar precipitation estimates in cold climates is much less common. In cold
climates, precipitation is in the form of snow, rain or a mixture of the
two phases. Air temperature is intrinsic to the phase of the precipitation
and could therefore be a possible covariate in the models used to ascertain
radar precipitation estimates. In the present study, we investigate the use
of air temperature within a non-parametric predictive framework to improve
radar precipitation estimation for cold climates. A non-parametric predictive
model is constructed with radar precipitation rate and air temperature as
predictor variables and gauge precipitation as an observed response using a
k nearest neighbour (k-nn) regression estimator. The relative importance
of the two predictors is ascertained using an information theory-based
weighting. Four years (2011–2015) of hourly radar precipitation rates from
the Norwegian national radar network over the Oslo region, hourly gauged
precipitation from 68 gauges and gridded observational air temperatures were
used to formulate the predictive model, hence making our investigation
possible. Gauged precipitation data were corrected for wind-induced
under-catch before using them as true observed response. The predictive model
with air temperature as an added covariate reduces root-mean-square
error (RMSE) by up to 15 % compared to the model that uses radar
precipitation rate as the sole predictor. More than 80 % of gauge locations
in the study area showed improvement with the new method. Further, the
associated impact of air temperature became insignificant at more than 85 %
of gauge locations when the near-surface air temperature was warmer than
10 ∘C, which indicates that the partial dependence of precipitation
on air temperature is most useful for colder temperatures.
Abstract. In cold climates, the form of precipitation (snow or rain or mixture of snow and rain) results in uncertainty in radar precipitation estimation. Estimation often proceeds without distinguishing the state of precipitation which can be reliably specified as a function of associated air temperature. In the present study, we hypothesise that incident air temperature is related to the phase of the precipitation and ensuing reflectivity measurement, and therefore could be used in prediction models to improve radar precipitation estimates in cold climates. This is the first study to our knowledge that assesses the dependence 5 of radar precipitation on incident air temperature and presents a procedure that can be used for taking it into consideration.We use a data based nonparametric statistical approach for this assessment. A nonparametric predictive model is constructed with radar rain rate and air temperature as predictor variables and gauge precipitation as observed response using a k-nearest neighbour (k-nn) regression estimator. A partial information theoretic technique is used to ascertain the relative importance of the two predictors. Six years (2011-2017) of hourly radar rain rate from the Norwegian national radar network over the Oslo 10 region, hourly gauged precipitation from 88 raingauges and gridded observational air temperature were used to formulate the predictive model and hence evaluate our hypothesis. The predictive model with temperature as an additional covariate reduces root mean squared error (RMSE) up to 15 % compared to the predictive model with radar rain rate as the sole predictor. More than 80 % of the raingauge locations in the study area showed improvement with the new method. Further, the estimated partial weight for air temperature assumed a zero value for more than 85 % of gauge locations when temperature was above 10which indicates that the partial dependence of precipitation on air temperature is most important for colder climates.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.