The potential drop (PD) crack growth measurement technique is sensitive to strain accumulation which is often erroneously interpreted as crack extension. When testing ductile materials these errors can be significant, but in many cases the optimum method of minimising or suppressing them remains unknown because it is extremely difficult to measure them experimentally in isolation from other sources of error, such non-ideal crack morphology. In this work a novel method of assessing the influence of strain on PD, using a sequentially coupled structural-electrical finite element (FE) model, has been developed. By comparing the FE predictions with experimental data it has been demonstrated that the proposed FE technique is extremely effective at predicting trends in PD due to strain. It has been used to identify optimum PD configurations for compact tension, C(T), and single edge notched tension, SEN(T), fracture mechanics specimens and it has been demonstrated that the PD configuration often recommended for C(T) specimens can be subject to large errors due to strain accumulation. In addition, the FE technique has been employed to assess the significance of strain after the initiation of stable tearing for a monotonically loaded C(T) specimen. The proposed FE technique provides a powerful tool for optimising the measurement of crack initiation and growth in applications where large strains are present, e.g. J-R curve and creep crack growth testing
This is a repository copy of A unified potential drop calibration function for common crack growth specimens.
To predict the residual life of components operating in the creep regime, it is vital to accurately identify crack initiation, and measure subsequent crack growth, in laboratory tests. Potential drop (PD) measurements, used for this purpose, are susceptible to errors caused by the accumulation of creep strain. For creep ductile materials, this can result in highly conservative crack initiation models and the implementation of unnecessary inspection and maintenance programmes that can cost millions of pounds in lost revenue. Conversely, the crack growth models can be non-conservative.Using a novel combination of interrupted creep crack growth (CCG) tests and sequentially coupled structural-electrical finite element analyses a new method of interpreting PD data has been developed and validated. It uses an increase in gradient on a plot of PD vs. load-line displacement to accurately identify crack initiation. This has been compared to the current method in ASTM E1457-15 by reanalysing data from CCG tests performed on a range of materials at various temperatures and loads. The initiation times, measured using the current ASTM method, were underestimated by factors of up to 23 and the subsequent crack growth rates were underestimated by factors of up to 1.5
One of the most common methods for estimating crack extension in the laboratory is electrical potential drop (PD). A key limitation of this technique is that it is sensitive to strains at the crack tip as well as crack extension. When producing J-R curves the onset of crack growth may be identified from a point of inflection on a plot of PD vs. CMOD. For creep crack growth (CCG) tests however, the effects of strain are often ignored. This paper investigates whether a similar method may be applied to CCG testing. A single CCG test was performed on type 316H stainless steel and a point of inflection, similar to that observed during J-R curve testing was identified. A finite element (FE) based approach was used to investigate this phenomenon further. A 3D sequentially-coupled structural-electrical FE model was used to reproduce the experimental PD vs. CMOD plot up to the point of inflection. The model was capable of predicting the general relationship between strain and PD. It predicted the magnitude of the change in PD to within 30%. A simplified 2D FE model was then used to perform a parametric study to investigate whether a similar trend may be expected for a range of materials. Power law tensile and creep properties were investigated with stress exponents of 1, 3 and 10. The results confirm that a point of inflection should be observable for the range of material properties considered.
The potential drop (PD) technique is one of the most common methods for determining crack growth; however, other factors can also change the resistance of the specimen, which may erroneously be interpreted as crack extension. In tough, ductile materials, plastic strain can cause a significant change in PD. This paper presents an experimental investigation which quantifies the apparent crack extension due to strain prior to the onset of physical crack growth and considers ways to mitigate it. Compact tension, C(T), and single edge notch tension, SEN(T), specimen geometries are considered with a range of crack lengths. The influence of probe location is also considered. The results identify apparent crack extensions of up to 1.0 mm in the absence of any physical crack extension. This can be reduced through careful selection of probe locations. Appropriate locations are suggested for the geometries considered. It is also shown that high constraint geometry can significantly reduce the influence of plasticity on PD.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
hi@scite.ai
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.