The molecular determinants responsible for the potency of the RXP470.1 phosphinic peptide inhibitor toward matrix metalloprotease-12 (MMP-12) remain elusive. To address this issue, structure-activity study, X-ray crystallography, and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) experiments were performed. The crystal structure of MMP-12/inhibitor complex (1.15 Å) reveals that the inhibitor establishes multiple interactions with the MMP-12 active site, with its long P(1)' side chain filling most of the S(1)' deep cavity. ITC experiments indicate that the binding of this inhibitor to MMP-12 is mostly entropy driven (ΔG° = -13.1 kcal/mol, ΔH° = -2.53 kcal/mol, and -TΔS° = -10.60 kcal/mol) and involves a proton uptake from the buffer. Comparing phosphinic versus hydroxamate inhibitors reveals that the chelation of the zinc ion is slightly different, leading the inhibitor backbone to adopt a position in which the hydrogen bonding with the MMP-12 active site is less favorable in phosphinic inhibitor while maintaining high affinity.

The most exploited strategy to develop potent zinc-metalloprotease inhibitors relies on a core zinc chelator and a peptidic or nonpeptidic scaffold that provides supplementary interactions for optimized potency and selectivity. Applied to matrix metalloproteases (MMPs) with highly conserved catalytic domains, this strategy failed to identify inhibitors with the desired selectivity profiles. To question the precise role of the zinc-binding group (ZBG), we have carried out a study on MMP-12 inhibitors with a common peptidic core but different ZBGs. We find that exchanging the ZBG modifies inhibitor positioning and affects its dynamics and selectivity. The binding properties of these compounds were compared through biochemical, structural, and calorimetric studies, showing a complex interplay between cooperative interactions and dynamics dictated by the ZBG. Improving selectivity will require expanding the ZBG repertoire within inhibitor libraries, since relying on a single ZBG significantly decreases our chance to identify effective inhibitors.