“…On the one hand, if helium is preferentially partitioned into Fe-Ni-S liquid, the Fe-Ni-S liquid could potentially store significant primordial noble gases compared with silicate crystals [Heber et al, 2007;Bouhifd et al, 2013;Huang et al, 2014]. On the other hand, if noble gases were to have higher silicate solid/liquid partition coefficients at high pressure (e.g., Xe: Sanloup et al [2011]), they could be stored in silicate phases rather than Fe-Ni-S liquids. In this scenario, the droplet occurrence would only have acted as a physical mechanism to isolate the LLSVP from whole mantle convection (through a density increase) but not as the host of the noble gases (especially Xe).…”