In this experiment we investigated the effect(s) on content comprehension of studying using different levels of elaborative rehearsals. The elaborative methods examined involved studying an article and then preparing and giving a 3-to 4-min presentation from either the first-person or the third-person perspective. A third (control) condition involved study only. A 17-item multiplechoice test was given during the following class period to assess the subjects' content comprehension for the article. The same test was readministered 2 weeks later to assess long-term content comprehension. Analysis of variance yielded significance for the groups factor for both test administrations. Specific contrast effects indicated that both the first-and third-person conditions produced significantly better content comprehension on the original testing occasion, whereas the third-person condition produced significantly greater content comprehension on the second testing occasion.Research that has investigated different levels of cognitive processing has demonstrated that elaborative rehearsal is a more effective means of encoding information than is simple maintenance rehearsal (Craik & Lockhart, 1972;Craik & Tulving, 1975;Craik & Watkins, 1973). More specifically , elaborative rehearsal purportedly leads to deeper levels of processing and better memory storage , whereas maintenance rehearsal is simply a repetitive process designed to maintain an item's availability in memory . However, in applying these fmdings to the classroom setting, it is important to consider the elaborative styles being employed. Older (1979), for example , discussed specific elaborative techniques used in an introductory psychology course . He contended that subject matter that is personally meaningful to students will enhance learning. Furthermore, Older suggested that experience is the most effective strategy for students to meaningfully incorporate new information. This view is in agreement with the views of Ausubel (1968) and Bruner (1961), who suggested that by organizing and structuring information in a meaningful manner, students can facilitate their understanding of that material.In view of the above-mentioned reports , the present investigation sought to examine the effect(s) that study.ing under different levels of elaboration would have upon content comprehension. More specifically, it was hypothesized that students who processed information at a high elaborative level would display higher scores subsequently on an objective test than would subjects who processed the same information at a lower elaborative level. Also , differences attributable to first-versus third-person elaboration were investigated.Requests for repr ints may be addressed to any of the authors at the Department of l-sychology, Emporia State University , Emporia , KS 66801-5087 .Copyright 1987 Psychonomic Society, Inc .
METHOD
SubjectsForty-two college students (21 males, 21 females) volunteered to serve as subjects. All students were enrolled in an introductory psycho logy c...