What Kind of a Girl Does Science? The Construction of School Science Identities

Abstract

A view of science as a culturally-mediated way of thinking and knowing suggests that learning can be defined as engagement with scientific practices. How students engage in school science is influenced by whether and how students view themselves and whether or not they are the kind of person who engages in science. It is therefore crucial to understand students' identities and how they do or do not overlap with school science identities. In this paper, we describe four middle school African American girls' engagement with science. They were selected in the 7th grade because they expressed a fondness for science in school or because they had science-related hobbies outside of school. The data were collected from the following sources: interviews of students, their parents and their teachers; observations in science classes; journal writing; and focus groups. These girls' stories provide us with a better understanding of the variety of ways girls choose to engage in science and how this engagement is shaped by their views of what kind of girl they are.

Identity, Critical Agency, and Engineering: An Affective Model for Predicting Engineering as a Career Choice

“…Lower identities in math and physics may lead to fewer women choosing engineering because they do not see themselves as the kind of person who can do engineering. This finding is consistent with other research that shows that STEM identities are essential to students' actual career choices (Brickhouse et al, ) and later persistence within that chosen career (Min et al, ).…”

Interested, Disinterested, or Neutral: Exploring STEM Interest Profiles and Pathways in A Low-Income Urban Community

“…In other words, by segmenting youth on the basis of STEM interest rather than gender, we found that there were as many STEM interested (and disinterested) girls as boys, a finding that was undetectable in the earlier comparison of STEM interest by gender. Our findings are in line with others who have reported that comparisons based on gender tend to exaggerate differences between the sexes while failing to recognize the diversity of interests within each group (Brickhouse et al, 2000).…”

Students’ motivation to study science: The case of Arab students in Israel

“…Therefore, girls invest more effort than boys in studies, especially in the field of science. This explanation is consistent with the conclusion of Brickhouse et al (2000) that to study science, it is necessary for students to see that their identities are compatible with the study of science. In addition, traditional Arab society does not allow girls to be away from home after school, and, therefore, girls spend more time studying and understanding the material.…”