1996
DOI: 10.1177/1354067x9600200307 View full text |Buy / Rent full text
|
|

Abstract: Tomasello disagrees with my position that language is the only human artefact that potentiates internalization. Tomasello's position seems to imply that language can be only verbal. My position is that every object or behavioural act is a symbol if it has all of the following characteristics: symbol must be an object or phenomenon that can be directly perceived through sense organs; meaning of symbols must be shared by organisms; symbols must refer to objects, events or phenomena; it must be possible to use a … Show more

Help me understand this report

Search citation statements

Order By: Relevance
Select...
1
1
1
1
0
10
0

Year Published

2003
2003
2015
2015

Publication Types

Select...
5

Relationship

4
1

Authors

Journals

0
10
0
Order By: Relevance
“…Every cultural sign (or Bsymbol^; the term that can be used synonymously with Bsign^in this context) is defined by four characteristics (Toomela 1996b). First, a sign must be an object, behavioural act or phenomenon that can be directly perceived through sensory organs.…”
Section: Hpfs Are Mediated By Symbolsmentioning
Create an account to read the remaining citation statements from this report. You will also get access to:
  • Search over 1b+ citation statments to see what is being said about any topic in the research literature
  • Advanced Search to find publications that support or contrast your research
  • Citation reports and visualizations to easily see what publications are saying about each other
  • Browser extension to see Smart Citations wherever you read research
  • Dashboards to evaluate and keep track of groups of publications
  • Alerts to stay on top of citations as they happen
  • Automated reference checks to make sure you are citing reliable research in your manuscripts
  • 14 day free preview of our premium features.

Trusted by researchers and organizations around the world

Over 100,000 students researchers, and industry experts at use scite

See what students are saying

rupbmjkragerfmgwileyiopcupepmcmbcthiemesagefrontiersapsiucrarxivemeralduhksmucshluniversity-of-gavle
“…Every cultural sign (or Bsymbol^; the term that can be used synonymously with Bsign^in this context) is defined by four characteristics (Toomela 1996b). First, a sign must be an object, behavioural act or phenomenon that can be directly perceived through sensory organs.…”
Section: Hpfs Are Mediated By Symbolsmentioning
“…I show why semiotic mediation in Vygotskian-but not necessarily Vygotsky's, because we need to go beyond him-sense can emerge only in the social environment. Many of the ideas presented next have been discussed elsewhere as well (Toomela, 1996a(Toomela, , 1996b(Toomela, , 2003. 8…”
Section: The Fundamental Epistemological Differences Between Vygotskimentioning
“…Language is a social phenomenon, when using language, humans are using symbols (words, charts, diagrams, etc. ) either in ways or in contexts that are different from ways or contexts of utilization of symbol referents (Toomela 1996b). This ability allows humans to build hypotheses about the world beyond senses, to process information in a qualitatively novel way-a way that seems unavailable to any other species inhabiting the earth (Kikas 2003;Toomela 1996aToomela , 2003a.…”
Section: Social Processes In Collaborationmentioning